Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Anna2, Sunday, March 05, 2017, 11:51 (3544 days ago)

On my way to the airport to return a Thrifty rental car after a month of safe driving, a fender bender :( Not my fault, no one hurt, very quickly processed with adjudicator/insurance etc. No responsibility for the other car.

BUT. Always BUT. I was sent e-copies of my bill and VISA charge. I am being charged for the full cost of the repair to my car. When I asked why I was not being charged a deductible, this is the answer:
"We dont charge the deductible beacuse is not a total lost o the car, we charge you only for the damage in the car and the information in the websites abouts deductible and rates for insurances is not the same in all the places."

I did not get copies of my papers after the accident (I should have asked). I have asked for e-copes of my papers and a statement of the insurance policy.

Comments welcome.
Thank you

Avatar

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Talley Ho @, Playa la Ropa, Sunday, March 05, 2017, 12:35 (3544 days ago) @ Anna2

Didn't they make you purchase ALL of the coverage? That should cover it.

Contact Thrifty corporate in your home country.

Contact your credit card carrier. Many cover all but your deductible on rental cars.

Good Luck

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Gringo Viejo @, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Sunday, March 05, 2017, 13:13 (3544 days ago) @ Anna2

"File a dispute" over the charge with your credit card company, you can probably do it on line.

The charging person (rental car company)has to follow a really strict set of rules and procedures in order to make the charges stick. For example, they must provide the credit card company with an estimated charge for repair within a certain period od time. And a lot of other things. Most companies do not follow the proper procedure and the credit card company will disallow their charge.

I have done this twice. "Won the case" both times with a minimum of fuss.

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Mexalberta @, Sunday, March 05, 2017, 14:37 (3544 days ago) @ Gringo Viejo

Had the same thing happen in San Pancho. Went to corporate Thrift etc. Our company rents hundreds of vehicles from them every year, although I am retired I still have a corporate id for rentals. my appeal was not recognized as a valid issue. We had the full insurance coverage and it still was not enough.
Finally I told them I was going to take them to small claims court.
I only ended up paying the deductible. Don't take no for an answer.

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Sunshine, Canada, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Wednesday, March 15, 2017, 05:58 (3535 days ago) @ Mexalberta

After being hit by a bus in our rental while vacationing in Zihuatanejo my husband and I never rented a car again. It was a real adventure to say the least but in the end we did not need to pay anything. I kind of miss not having a vehicle for a few days it was always fun exploring off the beaten path on our own. Hope everything works out OK for you and glad no one was hurt.

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Anna2, Wednesday, March 22, 2017, 13:33 (3527 days ago) @ Anna2

I have tried several times to get in writing what is covered by the various insurances at Thrifty car rental - even getting local spanish speaking friends to talk directly to the manager. He will email me every bill and report but NOT EVER a written summary of the insurance policies.

I went to the Hertz desk and pretended to be an interested client and asked what is covered by the insurances offered:
-mandatory: all tourists must take out this one. Small cost over and above car rental. Be sure to ask if it is included in car rental quote or not.
-Collision Damage Waiver (CDW): moderate extra cost, bringing the total daily rental to about $20-25 US/d. COVERS ONLY COST OF CAR IF TOTALLED = UNREPAIRABLE. There is no deductible charged if the car is totalled. At least, this is what I get verbally each time.
Comprehensive Insurance -doubles the daily cost of the car, will provide coverage for minor repairs, not sure if there is a deductible.

I plan to continue to question head office, my VISA, etc. if only to be able to clearly understand for future possibilities. My cost for repair to rental car was reasonable so I'm not going to fight further with threats to small claims or hire a lawyer etc.

Any further advice always welcome, and thanks for tips so far,
Anne

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by Elena S @, Tacoma WA USA, Thursday, March 23, 2017, 13:53 (3526 days ago) @ Anna2

I would report it to my insurance agent at home. They may be able to recover the charges for you.

Rental Car fender bender - advice

by OlsenMN, Thursday, March 23, 2017, 14:03 (3526 days ago) @ Anna2

This is what Profeco is for. Start with telling them you are going to Profeco and if the threat does not work go and file a complaint.