Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Friday, July 01, 2011, 13:13 (5621 days ago)
El arqueólogo no está ganando mentes y corazones en La Chole.
Cuando el río suena es que agua lleva...
Amenazan con expulsar de La Soledad de Maciel a antropólogo del INAH
Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by Sharkboy
, Barra de Potosi, Friday, July 01, 2011, 15:40 (5621 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Huff! esa persona viene a investigar, eso ayudara a la comunidad, por otro lado tal vez el trata a las personas como si fuera el de superioridad, eso es malo,. en fin veremos en que termina esto. gracias por el aviso Rob
Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Friday, July 01, 2011, 16:19 (5621 days ago) @ Sharkboy
Hola, Avi! Por favor, use el traductor de mi mensaje anterior. Estoy estudiando español ahora, pero no lo suficiente todavía para escribir para ti! Realmente me gustaría que lo lea.
Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by Donnyboy
, Atwater,California, Friday, July 01, 2011, 17:58 (5621 days ago) @ islandgirl
Well put and very insightful . Can't wait to tour the site in Nov when we are down. Having been to tulum/chitza and other sites in Mexico , wii be great to see it in it's infancy. (before the big tour buses start rolling through!)
Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Friday, July 01, 2011, 20:39 (5621 days ago) @ Donnyboy
Thanks, but just a few of my thoughts. Glad it is not something that I have to decide, because it's a tough call. Best when everyone sits down to find a solution together. Actually, it's a bit of a no brainer, but might be tricky to reach. Villagers need to make a living, Govt wants to excavate site. Should be able to figure that one out, but sometimes other things factor in. Just glad I don't have to make the call.
Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Friday, July 01, 2011, 16:12 (5621 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Most interesting article. I think I have the jist of it, but the translations are a bit wonky sometimes. Sounds like the archaeologist is annoying the villagers. Could be an anthropologist, but likely an archaeologist. Archaeologist says he/gov't bought all the land. The villagers say it was an illegal sale. Archaeologist is trying to protect the integrity of the site, which is a huge undertaking. The villagers are trying to plant gardens and crops.
This is a 'refer to Solomon' question I think.
If Arch. sites are plowed, dug up or otherwise disturbed, all knowledge about the site can be lost. Happens here all the time. Developers go in with excavators, claim afterwards that they didn't know and didn't see the skulls and stone tools rolling around. Then the archaeologists are hired to go in and literally sift through the mountains of midden left piled up. This salvage operation is just that, salvaging artifacts and human remains, often very damaged. These things, taken out of the context of the site itself, tell you very little about what was happening there. Hamburger Archaeology, I call it. No science at all. Properly studied, a site can tell you so much about the people that occupied it. Health, diet, local weather, society, pastimes, lifestyle, flora, fauna,.....Government here has Heritage Conservation Act, which makes it illegal to harm an archaeological site, regardless of whether you know it is one or not. However, on the other hand, developers can just apply for an 'Alteration permit' that allows them to legally carry on with the destruction. It seems to be part of the whole colonization mentality. Destroy all evidence of the First Nations people's use and occupation, and then you can carry on living on the land that has been stolen from them and getting rich from the resources of that land, while they live in third world conditions right here in good old Canada. When I sing the national anthem, I really mean 'home & NATIVE land!!! And for those of you not familiar with British Columbia, most of it has never been subject to treaties with the First Nations, so it is truy stolen land. Natives have taken this to court and the courts have ruled First Nations do hold aboriginal title to the land, but the gov't doesn't like that and continues to stall and deny it. Only a small part of the NE corner of the province and some very small areas around the SW coast have been covered by treaties. But I digress....
The villagers need to use the land that they've lived on for generations, and very likely inherited from the original inhabitants of the site. They need land to survive, and some should be made available to them, the closer the better, IF the Arch site is to be saved. Quite possibly, the villagers could move back once excavations are finished, but this could be many years.
Which brings me to this thought. Having been to La Chole in March, I was amazed at the extent of this site. It is truly incredible, and that's only what can be seen so far! I remember reading before my visit, that at first they didn't think this site was of much importance. That seemed to change when the pyramids and particularly the ball court were found. From what I saw, this will prove to be a major site, right up there with other more famous sites in Mexico and central America. Done properly, this could be one of the biggest attractions of the area and really pump up the visibility of Zihua and surrounding area, as well as be a major boost to the economy.
Somebody better get to La Chole in the meantime, and do a little peacemaking! With some common sense, this could work out to be fantastic for everyone involved.
Oh, one more thing, local people should be hired to work at the site. It doesn't take a lot to train field assistants, but they do need training (maybe about a week long course done right there on the gorund). These assistants will then understand too, why the archaeologist is flipping out over planting, and can help to make this situation less volatile by translating to the other villagers from archaeologists language into villagers language. And the field assistants will have new knowledge and appreciation of the site they are working on. I think Adnan could skip the training 'tho. I'd hire him in a minute! This kind of local knowledge can be invaluable, altho' I've heard locals aren't included in the work being done. That was a huge mistake. That's why I figure it's an archaeologist. Anthropologist not likely to do something so ethnocentric.
"according to the testimonies of the inhabitants of La Soledad de Maciel, this gentleman In the three years he has been doing excavation work, has denied that the villagers photographs taken to pieces that has managed to recover and that curiously does not appear in the local museum. "
Not the best translation, but if the recovered artifacts are not displayed in the museum, where did they go? Does the government take them? Did the anthropologist take them?
Missing artifacts
by LadyM in Zihua, Saturday, July 02, 2011, 16:59 (5620 days ago) @ Dione
That is the 100,000 dollar question. Where are they.?
Eminent Domain
by Dione
, Chicago, IL, Saturday, July 02, 2011, 17:02 (5620 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua
If the villagers can not plant will the government pay them for the land so that they can relocate?
Eminent Domain
by LadyM in Zihua, Saturday, July 02, 2011, 17:12 (5620 days ago) @ Dione
Only my opinion, but why should they move if they do not want to move. Pay them? Hardly works out exactly like that, I don't think.
Eminent Domain
by Dione
, Chicago, IL, Tuesday, July 05, 2011, 16:04 (5617 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua
I totally agree with you, they should not have to move. I was just curious to see if Mexico had something equivalent to eminent domain, like we do here in the states. In Illinois the use of eminent domain is being grossly abused.
Eminent Domain
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, July 05, 2011, 18:30 (5617 days ago) @ Dione
I hate to state the obvious, but unfortunately with respect to laws, Mexico is not like the USA. It doesn't matter what laws we have or don't have. People in power often do whatever they want with impunity here, especially in Guerrero. (Though with the Casey Anthony trial outcome, just like OJ, it looks like you CAN get away with murder, especially if you get a lot of media circus coverage).
The government at all levels has not treated the people of La Chole with decency and respect.
Eminent Domain
by D-Loco, Wednesday, July 06, 2011, 00:52 (5617 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Getting away with murder is no easy task here. The two examples you use were high profile, but both were lost by keystone cops and prosecuters that charged for what they couldn't prove. Death penalty with no witnesses, weapon or a motive that could be proven? For example (and only an example): she got f'd up one night on booze and pill partying, the daughter drowned in the tub, she lied and lied after covering up. She should be put to death because of what she did post death and because she didnt come clean about it?
Maybe the justice system worked this time, in an odd way.
Eminent Domain
by LadyM in Zihua, Wednesday, July 06, 2011, 01:10 (5617 days ago) @ D-Loco
They did not charge her with something they could prove. Too bad. And I guess I believe if a jury of her peers said Not Guilty then she is not.
Eminent Domain
by frostbite
, Hamilton MT, Wednesday, July 06, 2011, 08:46 (5616 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua
Being found not guilty does not necessarily mean that she was innocent; just that they were not able to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. I'm just glad that this theatre is finally over and the news organizations can go back to reporting on important matters.
Eminent Domain
by LadyM in Zihua, Wednesday, July 06, 2011, 08:55 (5616 days ago) @ frostbite
Let us know when they do that.
By our system she is NOT GUILTY whether we like it or not.
THE POINT BEING...
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Wednesday, July 06, 2011, 10:02 (5616 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua
My oblique reference was not meant to be a new topic of discussion. The point being that impunity in Mexico is the norm and that murderers and other criminals are most likely to get away with their crimes while our jails are AT LEAST half filled with folks who pass years locked up without ever having had a trial while the great majority of criminals enjoy complete impunity, often with the complicity of corrupt "public servants".
Liberan a indígena luego de 12 años preso por un homicidio que no cometió
Incidents like this are the norm here, not the exception as most of you folks are accustomed to. So powers of eminent domain or any other laws are applied whimsically, not uniformly, usually because some public servant is able to exert influence to their benefit.
Several times during the past years I have heard from folks at La Chole after they were threatened by the honchos at the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia (INAH) for one reason or another, in almost every case the problem was usually something that was said or done by them or someone else (including comments and actions by readers here) that either criticized the INAH or otherwise affected their image negatively. Personally, I get the impression that they ARE trying to get away with something. I don't know if it's marketing artifacts or simply trying to reap other economical or political benefits from the archaeological zone. But that's just a suspicion due to their own sometimes vindictive and less than transparent actions.
Missing artifacts
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Sunday, July 03, 2011, 00:55 (5620 days ago) @ Dione
My guess is that the missing artifacts are stored away, possibly in a larger museum facility. From what I researched before going to La Chole, Adnan had collected hundreds if not thousands, and I too, wondered when touring the new museum why so few were there. Then I remembered that most museums have more in their storage facilities than ever go on display. I've been into these areas in the Nat'l Museum of Civilization and the Nat'l Gallery in Ottawa, and the Royal BC Museum in Victoria. It's like they keep the really cool stuff hidden away from the public! Absolutely amazing things stored away.
The two main questions are: to preserve and study this site or not? how do the villagers survive?
Sounds like somebody from the Mexican government dept. (can't remember the initials) that deals with archaeology needs to get into that village and sit down and explain to the people exactly what they are doing, planning to do, and have done, like where the artifacts are. Start building relationships and incorporate the villagers concerns and ideas into planning and strategy. Could be a great project, given a little TLC.
Missing artifacts
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, July 25, 2011, 13:29 (5597 days ago) @ islandgirl
While there indeed will be pieces stored for future study and possible display, locally the inhabitants of La Chole are allegedly accusing the so-called archaeologist (apparently according to several sources he doesn't actually have a degree in this field) of trafficking in archaeological pieces, and when they threaten to go public he allegedly threatens back by saying he will simply accuse them of the same, and that it will be his word against theirs. Apparently he also has the backing of his superiors at INAH Guerrero who are also alleged not to be entirely professional in their duties, shall we say, but instead are alleged to be complicit with the exploitation of the La Chole site and its artifacts for their personal benefit. These allegations and others against the INAH Guerrero folks are being made by locals. So unfortunately it isn't simply a matter of having someone from INAH come and sit down and talk about it, since it isn't clear how high up the apparent corruption goes.
For many years there were indeed pieces from La Chole sold by a little old woman (Doña Agustina) who would come often to Playa La Ropa until the early 90's to sell pieces mostly to the gringos as well as locals and other tourists, some of which have been returned to La Chole by at least one local I am aware of. So it was indeed a common practice in the past. But since those days the locals have endeavored to protect the artifacts and their cultural heritage, only to have an outsider and the bureaucrats he works for take away the artifacts and exclude almost all the locals from any involvement with the museum or the archaeological attraction. I won't be recommending folks visit there until I am satisfied the community's inhabitants are benefitting justly from the archaeological treasure that is their birthright and that they are not being exploited, threatened or otherwise harassed by folks at INAH Guerrero.
Missing artifacts
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Monday, July 25, 2011, 15:45 (5597 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Thanks. Same problem with pothunters (the term for those who dig, collect and buy or sell) around the world. If anyone who is familiar with the artifacts could keep an eye on the internet...There are many sites that have illegally gained artifacts & sacred objects for sale. Sometimes you get lucky.
It's unfortunate the governments here and there do not have the will to do what is right. Maybe it comes down to respect, or the gov'ts lack there of.
Here they allow sites to be bulldozed for development, and there, the problems at La Chole.
Any news on the subject, as it occurs would be appreciated. I think keeping the issues in the spotlight, even here on only one site can help a bit.
Missing artifacts - read this
by islandgirl
, Cowichan Valley, Friday, July 08, 2011, 10:38 (5614 days ago) @ Dione
Here's an article that will give you an idea of what museum's have stashed away. And the Vancouver museum is not what you'd call a large museum. The big ones are packed and even little ones have lots of interesting pieces.

