Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by tropicslover, Monday, September 05, 2011, 18:35 (5555 days ago)

After a long walk on Playa El Palmar in Ixtapa on Saturday, I was ready for a swim. I was at the far end of the the beach near the marina, at a spot I have gone swimming in at least 15 times previously. The area close to shore is somewhat sheltered by the jetty, and until that day I thought it was pretty fair for swimming. I knew the recent storms had affected the waves, tides, and possibly the currents, and thought I would play it safe by only going in about waist high. I had looked at the area for several minutes before I went in the water, and didn't notice anything unusual. There was a yellow caution flag nearby, but those are almost normal for that beach.

I was maybe about 40 feet from shore in water that didn't even cover my swim trunks when I saw a wave coming in that was about 4 to 5 feet high. As usual, I dove underneath it, but saw another one coming in about the same height. There was an exceptional suction in the direction of the open ocean at my feet, and I dove underneath the second one as well. I was not able to stand up after the suction from the second one knocked me off my feet, and then a third one came in. By this time I knew I had to swim my way out of this situation, but I was being pulled out to sea. After less than two minutes had passed, I was now about 100 yards away from shore and getting pounded by bigger waves of anywhere from 8 to 12 feet. I know you don't try and fight them by trying to swim back to shore, so I tried swimming parallel to shore. That helped, but I kept on having to contend with giant waves. I knew I was in trouble so I started waving to the local surfers that were about 30 to 40 yards away. I yelled “socorro!” and “ayuda!” for help a number of times, but realized that they had seen me and were coming. I think I had 5 surfers come over to help me, including one that swam out from shore with a life preserver, and they were able to save me, with one of them giving me his board before one of the other ones got out to me with the life preserver. I was incredibly tired at that point, and I don't think I would have made it without their help. Thank God (¡Gracias a Dios! ) I had their help or I likely would not be typing this right now. I thanked them profusely and talked with them for a while, and will be back next week with soft drinks and water.

There aren't too many people that are in better physical condition than me, I don't drink and don't smoke, and I am an excellent swimmer. I have swum hundreds of times at beaches before, from the Atlantic to the Gulf of Mexico, to the entire Caribbean and many different parts of the Pacific, and consider myself pretty cautious about swimming in the ocean. In addition to that, I have lived here over a year and have been to many beaches in this area. However, maybe I got a little complacent, and after thinking about it a bit, and counting my blessings, I have learned some lessons that I hope are of benefit to others. They are:

1) Never, ever, take the ocean for granted. Conditions can change quickly, and you always should be alert. Don't ever be complacent. There were dangerous rip tides present where I was at, and even highly experienced swimmers can drown. It turns out that the locals had rescued another guy about half an hour before me, several hundred yards down the beach.
2) Ask the locals for advice on whether it is safe to swim where you are at if you have any doubt. Ideally, be on a beach with lifeguards, (which many times is not possible here) and always swim with other people present. There were other people present where I was at, but I probably should have been closer to them to begin with.
3) Unless you are close to people, you are going to get their attention better by flailing your arm then you are by yelling for help. I same “arm”, because if you use both arms, you will have a harder time staying afloat. The locals saw me waiving my arm, and could not hear me with the noise of the surf. I realized pretty quickly that yelling tires you out even faster, and you run the real risk of sucking water into your mouth and lungs if you get hit by a wave that you didn't see. Had I inhaled water, I probably would have died before being rescued.
4) If you have been drinking, don't even think about swimming in the ocean. Had I not had my faculties about me, I would not have survived, although I was still a little disoriented. The longer you are out there struggling against the waves and the currents, the more you will become disoriented and confused. Adding alcohol or other substances to the equation could prove deadly.

At any rate, I know this is a long post, but hope that it helps keep you safe and will do some good!

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by K&B @, Monday, September 05, 2011, 18:53 (5555 days ago) @ tropicslover

Thanks for the posting and excellent advise. Glad you were around to write it.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by El Tacaño, Monday, September 05, 2011, 19:11 (5555 days ago) @ tropicslover

Fortunately a cheap lesson for us all. Thanks for posting.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by LadyM in Zihua, Monday, September 05, 2011, 20:08 (5555 days ago) @ tropicslover

Very happy you are alive and well to post this. I never get in the water in Ixtapa for the reasons you mentioned. When I have gone in at La Barra, Las Gatas and La Ropa (No matter how shallow the water) I always make sure someone knows I am in and how bad a swimmer I am.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by Ottawa Joe, Monday, September 05, 2011, 20:32 (5555 days ago) @ tropicslover

You are soooo right about the ocean and it power. 20 years ago my wife and I were out in the water off Barbadoes and the rip was taking us out to sea with no one to help we swam sideways for our life for at least 1/2 hour and finally came to a point we could touch bottom. Even if you are good at body surfing the exhaustion can get to you, all please pay heed to this thread!!

Avatar

Excellent advice!

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, September 05, 2011, 21:00 (5555 days ago) @ tropicslover

First, I am extremely glad you were not injured or worse. The area near the jetty, Las Ecolleras, is known to be a treacherous swimming area due to the way the waves bounce around there and create riptides and dangerous currents. Most of Playa El Palmar is risky swimming, especially at this time of year. I believe the safest area to swim is just to the south side of the Barceló.

You did everything right, but you can never count on folks to respond correctly to a swimmer in trouble. You were fortunate to have surfers nearby since they are some of the few people who generally pay attention in the water to the other folks around them. I am also an excellent swimmer, but I got caught in a riptide in front of the original Burro Borracho many years ago trying to "rescue" (or so I thought) my daughter who was on a boogie board. Since she thought I was going to scold her she easily caught a wave in just before I reached her, and next thing I knew I was alone in waves just like you describe, one after another. I waved and shouted to folks on the shore... and they waved back. There are no words... It actually made me so angry to see such utter stupidity that I got enough of an adrenaline rush to save myself in spite of the waving idiots on the beach. :devil:

Excellent advice!

by Lee@98223, Monday, September 05, 2011, 22:03 (5555 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

For a change, a post accepted "as is".

Excellent advice!

by ElAleman, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 08:11 (5554 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I'm also glad that the adventure had a happy end. The Mexican version is:
don't fear the ocean, but you have to respect it
No hay que tener miedo al mar pero respeto.

What refers to your comment Rob I really do not understand why you have to qualify and offend other people.

Avatar

Excellent advice!

by Pelicano, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 16:02 (5554 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

As a regular La Madera swimmer when I'm in town, I worry more about wandering crocs than anything else...
:kingtut:

Avatar

Excellent advice!

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 18:08 (5554 days ago) @ Pelicano

I'm sure you're much too scary for our local crocs who prefer much smaller and less agressive prey. I've never heard of a swimmer being lost to one in Zihuatanejo yet. ;-)

Avatar

Excellent advice!

by Pelicano, Wednesday, September 07, 2011, 09:09 (5553 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

Yep, they probably like a pelican now and again, I should have chosen a different moniker....:fiddle:

Excellent advice! Dangers of swimming in the ocean-

by tropicslover, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 18:29 (5554 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

Thanks for the kind words from those who posted them, and I hope my experience with riptides will prove helpful to as many people as possible. As far as your experience with the people waving back, Rob, that could have happened to me if there hadn't been surfers there who are keenly aware of their environment. Also, regular swimmers would not have been able to help me unless they had a surf board or life preserver, either. Wow, you are lucky, as well as the others who posted about experiencing riptides.

The surfers did say that the best (i.e., safest) place to swim on Playa El Palmar in Ixtapa is near the Hotel Barcelo, by the way, just as you thought.

I had a few other thoughts that may be helpful.

1) If you are reluctant to ask a local (Spanish-speaking person) about the safety of swimming at the beach you are at because you don't know the language, you could keep it real simple and basic. Ask: “Es peligroso aqui? (pronounced “ess pelly-grosso ahh-key?) for “Is it dangerous here?” and point to the water at the same time. They will understand. Plus, many of them speak at least a few words of English. In addition to the obvious “Si”, or “No”, listen for “Hay corrientes aqui”, (pronounced “I corddy-entays ahh-key), their version of “There are currents, or riptides, here”.
2) One of my brothers who went through SCUBA certification said that they were advised to not swim near jetties or breakwaters because of the possibilities of strong currents and riptides. That makes sense to me now, even though it seemed like a more protected area, and good advice to follow.
3) If you feel you are getting in trouble, don't hesitate to wave your arm for help EARLY in the process (and hope for the best). I'm glad I decided not to play macho man. Things happen quickly, and every second you waste is critical if you are in trouble.
4) Don't swim at night (I have seen many nationals-usually vacationers- doing this, up to as late as midnight. Not only would somebody not be able to see you in many cases, but there are some interesting creatures in the ocean that are more active at night. If you have any doubts, just go to the Municipal Pier in Zihuatanejo at night and look around in the water with the benefit of the lights there.

All this being said, by all means, come down and visit the incredible people, beaches, and scenery that that are here on the Pacific coast of Mexico. Don't be afraid of the sea, just respectful, to paraphrase ElAlemán in his post. I am thankful every day that I get to live here. If you can't live here, just visiting will do wonders for you, as so many people know. Life's too short-enjoy it while you can!

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by HolyMole, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 12:40 (5554 days ago) @ tropicslover

Thank you for this. Many of us believe that our swimming skills would preclude us from getting caught in your kind of situation. Wrong.
I don't often get over to Playa Palmar anymore , but I've always felt safe there as long as I didn't go out too deep. I'll now have to rethink what is "too deep". Same for Troncones, La Ropa, La Madera and the south end of La Barra. For me, the scary places are Playa Larga and Playa Blanca, which all have their annual share of drownings.

On another side of beach and swimming dangers, has anyone else seen the horrific video currently making the rounds, showing a fellow being attacked by two Orcas/killer whales while walking in ankle-deep water? I don't know how to post it here, but wouldn't anyway: it is the most upsetting thing I've seen in years. I raise it because the captions are in Spanish, but don't identify the locale. I've never heard of Orcas in the Zihua area, but I saw them myself further south, in Puerto Escondido, Oaxaca. I can't see whales coming that close to shore in shallow waters like La Ropa, La Madera or most of Troncones, but the water at Playa Larga/Blanca gets deep fairly close to shore. This damn video now has me spooked over simply walking those latter beaches.

Danger of Orca's to people= very low

by halibut_man, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 13:43 (5554 days ago) @ HolyMole

I thank the author of the original thread on ocean / beach swimming safety and any others who provided useful information. Ocean swimming safety is something that a lot of us could use assistance and more information on.

Learn as much as you can and try to teach others what you have learned.
Where ever you are, mother nature provides amazing places to explore & recreate in...but as always, the more knowledgeable mankind is about it, the safer it is hopefully for both the person; and the ecosystem they are in.

That being said, some of us get to spend a lot of time and experience with different creatures that are part of the ocean system. I think if one looks at world wide interactions between mankind and Orca (killer whale), you will find that even though the Orca is an 'apex' predator, the danger to humans that don't swim with it intentionally, is almost non-existent.

There are some rare beaches world wide where it is known that Orca's utilize a predation tactic of grabbing prey off the beach, where the beach meets the water. A location in South America is one of the more famous.

Hope this helps...

Danger of Orca's to people= very low

by norm, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 17:53 (5554 days ago) @ halibut_man

We stay in that area every year and every year we see people washed out and unable to get back to shore.Usually a lifguard is around and is able to save them.Last year,on a Sunday after 6;00,no lifeuard,3 young strong
Mexicans were out swimming,no lifeguard, waves really picked up to about 10 feet,and they could not get back in.I ,77 years old and scrawny,ran down with boogie board,told some nearby fishermen that there were people out in the water and was met by a shrug.With my wife shouting at me "don't do it"I finally convinced someone else on shore to go out.He was promply knocked over by a wave.Finally an experienced surfboarder showed up,got the board out and saved them,They collapsed on shore grabbed each other and began sobbing in each others arms.30 minutes later police and lifeguards showed up.I always swim with a small inflatable swimtube in my pocket,but I bodysurf daily

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by kate, Tuesday, September 06, 2011, 23:10 (5554 days ago) @ tropicslover

I am so glad for you and your family that you survived. Not only do the oceans have riptides and fast currents, but we have had quite a few drownings in Lake Michigan the past few years for those very reasons. Some people just don't realize how dangerous it can be to swim near the piers when the waves are high. Most of our public beaches have flags to indicate whether or not the lake is safe for swimming, but some choose to ignore the warnings. Again, I am glad you are safe, and thank you for your advice.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by allen @, Pacific Northwest, Saturday, September 10, 2011, 22:12 (5550 days ago) @ tropicslover

About three years ago a friend of mine, Bruce, told me a similar story. He is a daily swimmer averaging a mile a day. He was merely wading in front of Mi Cas es su Casa in Troncones when he stepped into a hole and found himself being swept out. A friend on shore saw that he was in trouble and went out to help him with a short board. They then found themselves both in trouble. Luckily someone on shore saw this and grabbed their long board and saved them both. Taught me a lesson just hearing the story. All that being said, I had a friend (Craig Carlson a great poet) who took his 16 year old stepson to Zihua and while swimming at a beach that I am still unsure of, the 16 year old got caught in a rip and my friend went out to save him and they both drowned. The ocean is certainly never to be underestimated, even from shore.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by islandgirl @, Cowichan Valley, Saturday, September 10, 2011, 22:38 (5550 days ago) @ allen

I just googled out of curiosity about the poetry, and an obit says it happened of the Pacific Coast of Costa Rica. So we don't know which beach, or even which country!

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by allen @, Pacific Northwest, Sunday, September 11, 2011, 16:41 (5549 days ago) @ islandgirl

Odd, I attended his memorial and they said it was in Zihuatanejo.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by Sunseeker, Wednesday, May 15, 2019, 09:44 (2746 days ago) @ tropicslover

I just had to reply to this post. There are so many things that need to be clarified. You say you are an experienced swimmer yet what you write conflicts with that statement.
How can you even get tired when you can just float in seawater? If one cannot tread water effortlessly (in salt water) for long periods of time, like at least 30 minutes, one should not go out in waves. If a current takes you away from the beach you need to wait it out and patiently swim with it as much as you can until you can swim in. Sometimes it can take a while. Patience is key. For me, the beach at Ixtapa is the premier reason for coming to the area in the first place. I live in that ocean. I've spent months there several times at different times of the year. The waves at the northern end are fantastic for bodysurfing. Sure you get churned up a bit once in a while - its just a wave. No big deal. Its that washing machine feel....lol. Anybody that can't deal with that should high tail it to the geriatric Playa Ropa and swim in the lake like water there. Snooze.... You mention jetties....you don't go near a jetty or any rock outcropping because the waves can smash you against the rocks! I thought that was just common sense. Sort of like not sticking your hand in crevices when you're diving...common sense. Things bite so keep away from the bottom and enjoy the scenery safely. And never go in the water that you don't know underneath. If you have never used a mask in an area and there are waves there you don't know if there is coral or rock or sand below you. Sand is a lot safer than coral or rock! Waves are unpredictable and you just can't take chances. Its sand or nothing buddy! Your skull is rather unforgiving when it comes to impact. If you live there you should know this. Spend the next time exploring with a mask noting where those rocks are and stay well away because currents can move you very easily without you knowing it. They're kind of sly.... One trick with waves and the washing machine syndrome is to roll up like a ball so if you get pounded into the sand you won't hit your head. But obviously don't ever go into waves when there are rocks under or around you.
The real danger people tend to have is panic. Practice your floating position so when you're tired you can rest on your back. Because if you love the water, sooner or later things will happen that will demand an intelligent and rational response, not flailing and screaming for help that can exhaust anyone very fast.
Admittedly there are instances of people being dragged out to sea by currents. But this is probably because they didn't swim diagonally with the current to counteract it gradually. Currents change direction and its up to us to wait them out. At least the water is warm there - hypothermia ain't going to be a problem!
Probably another problem is people swimming after eating. As most tourists seem to have a never ending compulsion to stuff their faces and bloated bellies with an endless stream of high fat Mexican food when at the beach, its a deadly precursor to cramps which can be the death of most anyone swimming away from shore. Don't swim for hours after eating!

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by John Redcorn, Wednesday, May 15, 2019, 10:04 (2746 days ago) @ Sunseeker

Same thing happened to me at the same spot on my honeymoon 20 years ago.

I am an avid surfer so took the bus down to escolleras one afternoon to check the waves for the next day's possibilities. I was on the beach previously and had a few XX's, so by the time the bus made it to the marina I had to relieve myself.

I waded off the beach in waist deep water just as a huge set came rolling in. Like you, I instinctively dove under, but was pulled further offshore with each wave. Once the set passed, I realized I was in a pretty good rip and sitting 100 yards off shore.

Instead of swimming, I chose to tread water for a bit to get a game plan. The thought crossed my mind to swim around the jetty and into the harbor, but wasn't keen on seeing another big set come in and wash me into the rocks. Finally my only concievable options were to make the long swim at an angle to the beach, through the head high beach break or try for Ixtapa Island! I chose the beach. Luckily, being young, in good shape and knowledgeable of the ocean (despite foolishly wading out earlier) I made it in. It was a struggle and took a beating but alive non the less.

That spot is not to be taken lightly. Glad you made it in.

Dangers of swimming in the ocean- lessons learned!

by Sunseeker, Wednesday, May 15, 2019, 11:30 (2746 days ago) @ John Redcorn

This was a great example of how to deal with currents. He was patient, he swam diagonally to the current to make some progress but not exhaust himself and he stayed away from the rocks. Now if we could just spread this logic to everyone at the beach!