Sailfish dilemma

by Jon in SC, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 12:12 (5428 days ago)

There is a certain stigma for some people in North America about catching sailfish which is based on the idea that it is a game fish, and is not good for eating.  The idea being that the fish loses it's life for a tourist's photograph and then gets tossed in the trash.  As I have seen several a sailfish dropped of at restaurants in Zihua, and have enjoyed it many times in tiritas and once in a smoked sailfish quesadilla, I would tend to think that around these parts it is perceived differently, and considered as much an eating fish as any other.  I am wondering, then, about the 30 kilo sailfish we pulled in a couple weeks ago fishing with a guy and his son in his panga.  Besides the couple pounds he cut off in the boat and sent us home with (best tiritas ever, by the way) what, most likely, became of the rest of the sailfish?  Was it eaten by the fisherman, sold to a restaurant?  Most importantly, was it used or wasted? (I realize no one knows what happened to that exact fish, just looking for an educated guess)
    I have done some cursory Internet research about sailfish.  It is absent from Monterey bay seafood watch list, and IUCN lists it as a species of "least concern."  So assuming it is not a threatened species, and that it does get eaten, is there anything wrong with catching and killing a sailfish in Zihua?

Sailfish dilemma

by D-Loco, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 12:30 (5428 days ago) @ Jon in SC

It got eaten probably via a sale to the market.

I personally think it is very wrong.

Although a warm water bass isn't very good eats, would you keep a 8 - 12 LB'er in SC if it was or hang it on a wall? If yes then you are simply not a C&R fisherman. Sails and Marlins are game fish and we need the trophies to be there for future generations to enjoy just like bass, muskies and other trophy game fish. If you think they cant fished out just because its a big ocean you are mistaken. For tiritas try the smaller bonitos, nice white meat, abundant and easy to catch. For filets or whole sierras are outstanding as are tuna steaks, plenty available for purchase. Dorado I recommend releasing also.

Sailfish dilemma

by John Redcorn, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 12:54 (5428 days ago) @ D-Loco

Dorado reproduce and grow to maturity rather quickly. Catch and filet these in my opinion.

Sailfish dilemma

by Tess, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 13:41 (5428 days ago) @ Jon in SC

I remembered that this had been discussed here recently. Using the search box I came up with this thread:
Sailfish

It may answer your question.

Sailfish dilemma

by D-Loco, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 14:10 (5428 days ago) @ John Redcorn

Dorado reproduce and grow to maturity rather quickly. Catch and filet these in my opinion.

C&R is about a lot of things. To me it's about the future. It hit me about 25 years ago when explained and influenced by my fishing buddies. How we feel and what we choose about specific species is a personal choice. One or two times a year I'll keep 50 blue gills or crappies and chow 'em down. To someone else that could be wrong. There was a lake we ice fished that had 14 -16 inch perch. Any fisherman that is familiar with perch will tell you this is rare. It was lake that was hard to get to so it wasn't fished heavily. In 2 winters we fished them out and to this day those perch are no longer there, only the usual stunted 5 inchers that you normally find in inland lakes.

If you're not breaking the law by season, limit or size you are free to do what you wish. In Zihua it so easy to just buy the fish that have already been committed to harvest than to keep your own as long as you are not supporting someone else illegal catch.

Sailfish dilemma

by Senor Thomas, Tuesday, January 10, 2012, 15:58 (5428 days ago) @ Jon in SC

Long live the Sailfish of Zihua. A live Sailfish is much more beneficial to Zihua as a community vs a dead Sailfish. Catch and Release these awsome fish for future anglers to do the same.

Avatar

Sailfish dilemma // To My Mind, The Critical

by Sandy Beach in Toronto, Wednesday, January 11, 2012, 01:29 (5428 days ago) @ Jon in SC

factor may well be the severely declining size/weight of the average sailfish caught. It seems that back in the 70/80's, area sailfish were often in the 4-5/600 pound range. Currently, 1-200 lbs is most common?? Whether from fishing or pollution, or other causes, such a difference indicates a severe strain on the population of the given breeds which eventually will lead to severely declining numbers since oldest/largest breeders are gone.

Mind you, the smaller ones are probably "safer" eating due to less accumulated toxins in the flesh than in the very largest.

If the above is true, then catch & release seems to be the necessary mode for the longevity of the fishery & breeding stocks. JMHO. Sandy :omg: :-D :vivamexico:

Oh it was eaten

by halibut_man, Wednesday, January 11, 2012, 12:17 (5427 days ago) @ Jon in SC

The sailfish you caught was eaten.
Tiritas is pretty popular there.

Should you keep a sailfish from that area in the first place?

There is much discussion and communication on this subject in board archives.

Following the official rules and regulations for the area you are fishing is critically important and then if you can teach & demonstrate catch & release to someone else who will fish somewhere, in their life, is also very valuable as well.

Kudos for asking the questions...

Oh it was eaten

by Jon in SC, Thursday, January 12, 2012, 12:19 (5426 days ago) @ halibut_man

Thanks for all the responses so far, and yes I did read some other discussions from the archives, but I just wanted to get some other opinions to help me wrap my head around the issue.  Tricky one, for sure, and in the end it is a personal decision. Sort of depends how you want to think about it, I guess, and I suppose a case could be made for practicing catch and release with many of the species of fish getting pulled out of the bay (though certainly some a lot more than others).
    I'm glad to hear that the sailfish was likely eaten, anyway. Puts my mind at ease a bit. I was catching some flak from a friend at home for killing a fish that was "not a good eating fish," but I found it a bit ironic since it's mostly the fish that are considered to be "good eating" that are getting fished out of existence.  At any rate, I've pulled my last sailfish out of the bay.  I figure if I wouldn't buy it at the market, then I shouldn't be taking it out of the ocean, either.  Maybe someone who is thinking about charter fishing will read these posts and be convinced to do the same...
   Incidentally, we did pull a 20-30 kilo Dorado on the same trip, which I have no problem with, Dorado being as plentiful as they are delicious. The Monterey Bay Seafood Watch List(http://www.montereybayaquarium.org/cr/seafoodwatch.aspx) the go-to guide for selecting ocean friendly seafood, gives dorado a thumbs up.
Happy fishing