Oh it was eaten
Thanks for all the responses so far, and yes I did read some other discussions from the archives, but I just wanted to get some other opinions to help me wrap my head around the issue. Tricky one, for sure, and in the end it is a personal decision. Sort of depends how you want to think about it, I guess, and I suppose a case could be made for practicing catch and release with many of the species of fish getting pulled out of the bay (though certainly some a lot more than others).
I'm glad to hear that the sailfish was likely eaten, anyway. Puts my mind at ease a bit. I was catching some flak from a friend at home for killing a fish that was "not a good eating fish," but I found it a bit ironic since it's mostly the fish that are considered to be "good eating" that are getting fished out of existence. At any rate, I've pulled my last sailfish out of the bay. I figure if I wouldn't buy it at the market, then I shouldn't be taking it out of the ocean, either. Maybe someone who is thinking about charter fishing will read these posts and be convinced to do the same...
Incidentally, we did pull a 20-30 kilo Dorado on the same trip, which I have no problem with, Dorado being as plentiful as they are delicious. The Monterey Bay Seafood Watch List(http://www.montereybayaquarium.org/cr/seafoodwatch.aspx) the go-to guide for selecting ocean friendly seafood, gives dorado a thumbs up.
Happy fishing
Complete thread:
- Sailfish dilemma - Jon in SC, 2012-01-10, 12:12
- Sailfish dilemma - D-Loco, 2012-01-10, 12:30
- Sailfish dilemma - John Redcorn, 2012-01-10, 12:54
- Sailfish dilemma - D-Loco, 2012-01-10, 14:10
- Sailfish dilemma - John Redcorn, 2012-01-10, 12:54
- Sailfish dilemma - Tess, 2012-01-10, 13:41
- Sailfish dilemma - Senor Thomas, 2012-01-10, 15:58
- Sailfish dilemma // To My Mind, The Critical - Sandy Beach in Toronto, 2012-01-11, 01:29
- Oh it was eaten - halibut_man, 2012-01-11, 12:17
- Oh it was eaten - Jon in SC, 2012-01-12, 12:19
- Sailfish dilemma - D-Loco, 2012-01-10, 12:30

