Rental Car Scam!
I just returned from a wonderful week in Z and Troncones and had the worst rental car experience ever in the last 6 times I have rented. It was a discouraging experience. I will preface our story with we go to Hacienda Eden in a remote part of Troncones and spend the other half of our time in Z. A car is essential for having the flexibility to go into the town of Troncones and travel between the two cities and the airport. I am a fluent Spanish speaker which helped with negotiations and asserting our rights.
I had a reservation for a car through Expedia with Thrifty for $64 a week. When I arrived with my credit card insurance they would allow it however I also had to purchase liability insurance at the rate of $20 a day even though the year before it was $7 a day with Thrifty. I brought the terms of coverage from my Master Card detailing the exact coverage available on the card in Mexico and showed the attendant that liability insurance was a covered benefit. It was an exercise in futility. It was a super frustrating experience and ultimately I refused the rental on principal alone that the rental went from $64 to $270 even though my credit card had better coverage than what the attendant was offering. I then asked all the others at the rental car stands at the airport what their rates were and whether I could use the insurance on my credit card. All insisted that they could not rent me a car unless I paid for insurance. We took a taxi to our hotel in Z and then I searched online for another car rental deal.
I found a deal with Dollar where it actually said that in Ixtapa/Zihuatanejo all insurance was optional. I booked it and brought the agreement with us for proof the next day when we went by combi back to pick up the car and a friend at the airport. Let the games begin anew. The Dollar attendant told me that it is also their option to not rent to me unless I took the insurance and that he would lose his job unless I bought insurance with the car so if I wanted to rent a car I had to take the insurance. Another exercise in complete frustration!
I am thoroughly convinced that the insurance angle is a scam and it is the way they make money on their rentals. All of the money made on the rental cars and insurance is not put back into the cars, the worker's wages or the run down office, it is skimmed off the top and deposited into the franchise persons' pocket. I also wonder if it is the same franchise owner for all the rental car companies. The workers are not paid well and have to carry out the scam arguing with each rental client. The attendant said it gets very old and exhausting with each rental client.
The saga continues...I accepted a deal that was made for insurance at $14 a day. They gave me the dumpiest car they had with many dents, two cracked windshields, two levers that did not work, an empty gas tank and manual transmission. We took it and began driving only to discover that the speedometer did not work. We brought it back and explained that the speedometer was broken. The attendant said it was not a problem and that I could guess how fast I was going. I told him I was not guessing especially with signs that said radar en operacion on the highway. He then wanted me to get into the car and he would show me how fast I should drive by guessing. I insisted firmly that no, I would not take the car without a speedometer and I was not going to guess.
After further stalling and hesitation, they gave us another car but kept the original paperwork for the first car probably because they are not allowed to upgrade another level without charging more. We were finally on our way.
This year the main highway was under construction in Z which made for extra chaos because everyone makes their own lanes and butts in at the last minute making for very interesting and defensive driving. I am beginning to think that it is just not worth it to rent a car any more and possibly we will have to give up going to Troncones. Driving in Z is problematic enough but then to have to be ripped off at the rental counter is even more of a hassle. Taxis may be a better, less costly option.
A positive
trip report to come.
Complete thread:
- Rent A Car [3days] from Aiport to Troncones return Ixtapa - LaurieMac, 2012-01-28, 21:44
- Rent A Car [3days] from Aiport to Troncones return Ixtapa - LadyM in Zihua, 2012-01-28, 22:09
- Rent A Car [3days] from Aiport to Troncones return Ixtapa - Paulf, 2012-01-29, 08:44
- Rental Car Scam! - Sharon MN, 2012-01-29, 13:01
- Rental Car Scam! - Emmet, 2012-01-29, 13:05
- Rental Car Scam! - LadyM in Zihua, 2012-01-29, 13:07
- Rental Car Scam! US INsurance invalid in Mexico - Canadian Rainbirds, 2012-01-29, 15:31
- Rental Car Scam! US INsurance invalid in Mexico - HolyMole, 2012-01-30, 16:27
- Good advise from those that have..... - LaurieMac, 2012-01-30, 19:32
- Rental Car Scam! US INsurance invalid in Mexico - HolyMole, 2012-01-30, 16:27
- Rental Car Scam! US INsurance invalid in Mexico - Canadian Rainbirds, 2012-01-29, 15:31
- Rent A Car [3days] from Aiport to Troncones return Ixtapa - LadyM in Zihua, 2012-01-28, 22:09

