Avatar

Mexico's changing face

by Pelicano, Monday, September 10, 2012, 10:04 (5184 days ago)

Mexico's changing face

by Average Joe, Monday, September 10, 2012, 10:43 (5184 days ago) @ Pelicano

A justified article, for sure!

Though, it should be further noted that the advent of such growing consumer product availability goes well-beyond simple “corporate global expansion” interests.

Such widespread distribution of goods throughout México is due in VERY Large part to the past two Presidential administrations, which have dramatically increased both the quality and quantity of México’s infrastructure highway system…… Much like the due ‘kudos’ to America’s expansion with the 1800’s national railway system; to the post-Depression New Deal WPA public works projects, and to the post-WWII launching of the U.S. Interstate Highway System.

And while one can certainly fault both Fox AND Calderon for numerous shortcomings and/or policy short-sightedness, the laying of the operative foundation for México’s exponential ‘transfer of goods’ surely isn’t one them!

Mexico's changing face

by Scott ⌂, Mérida, Yucatán, Sunday, September 16, 2012, 23:07 (5177 days ago) @ Pelicano

I do not believe that the middle-class is growing in Mexico, or that increasing consumption of foreign goods in recent years is a sign of prosperity. I believe the increasing availability of foreign goods and the arrival of more foreign retail outlets is the natural outcome of the Mexican government abandoning the import substitution policies of the past, joining the WTO and negotiating NAFTA, in the early 1990s. It took a number of years for this monumental change in direction to be phased in, and now, about 20 years later, most of it is in place and many of the old trade barriers have been reduced or phased out by now.

Trade and the GDP per capita may be increasing in recent years, but this increased national income is not being enjoyed by most Mexicans. And I think articles like this, and the one from CNN that Rob shared last week, are misleading at best. For example, the CNN one suggested that the "annual purchasing power of the average Mexican" is $15,000. But numbers like this are based on GDP per-capita measured using purchasing power parity, which is not indicative of actual household income in Mexico, in my opinion. They do not mention anywhere in the article, intended for the lay person, that the $15,000 is actually a theoretical number, not something anywhere even remotely close to the actual per-capita income of the vast majority of Mexicans.

Numbers from Mexico's National Institute of Statistics and Geography (INEGI) tell a somewhat different story. The average per-capita income of the richest 10th of the population was 33,347 pesos / quarter in 2010, which works out to about $10,478 US / year, using today's exchange rate. The actual per-capita income of the richest decile is nearly a third less than the "purchasing power of the average Mexican" reported by CNN. The average per-capita income of the "middle deciles", the 5th and 6th, was 5,404 and 6,589 pesos / quarter, or about $1,700 US & $2,087 US / year, respectfully. The average income for all deciles of the population actually went down, in real terms (inflation adjusted 2010 pesos), in the latest periods reported by INEGI (2008 to 2010).

In terms of poverty, the number of Mexicans living in this condition increased in the latest years reported by INEGI. It shows that in 2006, there were 14,742,740 Mexicans who did not have enough household income to buy a "basic basket of goods" to feed themselves (canasta basica). In 2010, there were 21,204,441 people whose families could not afford a canasta basica, even if they spent all of their household income on food. And we're talking about things like beans, tortillas and eggs, not USDA-certified organic salad from Costco. In 2006, there were 45,502,304 Mexicans who could not afford the basic basket of food and their necessary health, education, clothing and shelter expenses, even if they dedicated all of their house
hold income to these things. In 2010, this number increased to 57,707,660 people in Mexico. That is 51% of the 2010 census population (112,336,538) who are living in poverty, as defined by INEGI.

When the number of Mexicans living in poverty is increasing, and the average per-capita income of all deciles (10ths) of the population is decreasing, it makes one wonder who exactly is this "growing middle class that is fast becoming Mexico’s majority [that] is buying more U.S. goods than ever, while turning Mexico into a more democratic, dynamic and prosperous American ally". It seems that the presupposition in these articles from the US media is that the availability of U.S. goods and retail chains can only be a good thing, and that the ability to patronize these places and consume U.S. goods is an indication of increasing prosperity and middle-class membership. But I'm not convinced.

When you look at a country like Cuba, whose citizens enjoy a higher quality of life according to the UN Human Development Index (which considers things that actually matter - like health, education and life expectancy, as opposed to PPP per capita or the ability of the discerning salad eater to purchase "prestigious" USDA-certified organic produce from Costco), even though they have relatively few foreign and especially U.S. goods, it makes it difficult to buy into this myth that Mexico is somehow becoming more prosperous, just because there are a bunch of big box stores and U.S. fast food outlets there now. When half of the country is still living in poverty, I tend consider the preferences of the discerning salad eater to be little more than conspicuous consumption. Not that there's anything wrong with that - as long as we recognize it for what it is. The reality is that while the fresas are worried about the prestige of their brand of salad, there's a national crisis in the country right now because the price of eggs went up $1.50 / kilo.

Sources:

Average per-capita income by decile:
http://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/sisept/default.aspx?t=mhog21&s=est&c=26512

Number of people living in poverty:
http://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/sisept/default.aspx?t=mhog24&s=est&c=26515

CNN article recently shared by ZihuaRob:
http://globalpublicsquare.blogs.cnn.com/2012/09/12/misreading-mexico/

The Great Egg Crisis
http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/the-great-egg-crisis-hits-mexico/2012/09/02/0f9ae31c-f3b6-11e1-b74c-84ed55e0300b_story.html

List of countries by UN human development index:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Human_Development_Index
(Cuba ranks 51st, Mexico 57th)

Mexico's changing face

by Lee@98223, Monday, September 17, 2012, 08:45 (5177 days ago) @ Scott

Scholarly!