Avatar

more on the the CAR STORY

by Linda from Canada @, Zihua and Grand Marais, Manitoba, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 09:23 (4965 days ago)

First a re-statement of the cause of the mess. There were new immigration laws passed this past season. Immigration controls the status of foreigners. We now have “permanent resident” status.

Because there are new immigration laws, aduana (customs) must create new regulations to accommodate the immigration changes. They have not done this yet, but should publicize their changes any day now….which could take several more months…or not. Aduana controls the status of foreign vehicles.

We entered with our XTrail in 2009. We were given a temporary import permission. Because we had FM3 status at that time, our vehicle was allowed to stay in Mexico as long as our status did not expire. Our new status, if the new rules of aduana are what everyone expects them to be, will not allow us to have a temporarily imported vehicle, because our status is not temporary any more. That means we cannot have a foreign plated vehicle. We knew this day would come, and had planned for it. We would simply nationalize our car and “permanently import it” which would allow us to put Mexican plates on it. So the day is here.

What we didn’t know before now, is that only NAFTA approved vehicles can be permanently imported. Vehicles that have VINs beginning with numbers are NAFTA approved. Ours, of course, begins with two letters. It cannot be permanently imported. Who would ever have known all this? Well, we do now!
However, there is an amparo in existence. This is a Mexican type of special allowance in the law which allows a certain border broker to permanently import some vehicles, for a limited period of time, which would otherwise not be allowed. This special allowance for him is the result of a court case that he won. It was part of his concession, and is for 2013 only. Our XTrail could be imported under this amparo. However, it is very likely that the Mexican government will appeal this concession and the amparo could very likely be overthrown, which would probably mean that any vehicles which were imported under the ampara would then become illegal again. If all that happened, which is evidently very likely, we would be out the approximate $4000.that it would cost for the importation taxes AND we would be back where we are now.

So, long story short, too much drama. Everyone in immigration and in customs gives us a different answer…yes your car is legal, no your car is not legal, yes you can permanently import it, no you can’t. We will be driving the XTrail back to Canada instead of flying, and when we return in Sept. we will buy a “new to us” used car here which will have Mexican plates on it and we will have no further issues for the rest of our lives. Haha right.

We still are being told, as of yesterday, by Aduana here in Zihua, that our car is legal. They say if it was legal before our immigration status changed, it is still legal as long as our status has never expired.

Well it's a long drive to the border and I would sure feel better to have some magic piece of paper in my hand, so I started looking into the seguro retorno (safe return) permit. I was told, again by aduana herem, that is only for Mexicans only. That is just not correct. I now have an address in centro for SAT (a division of hacienda evidently) who are supposed to be the ones to issue this permit. Will look into that one day very soon.

We are still working on making cancellations and changes to our flight arrangements. We were to fly Zihua to Calgary on June 1 and 2. Spend a day with daugher in Calgary, then a day with Paul’s brother, then fly to Wpg on June 4.
The plan now is to drive from Zihua to Calgary and still spend our time with daughter. We will leave Zihua on Saturday or Sunday, May 25 or 26. We should be home in Grand Marais on Tuesday or Wednesday, June 4 or 5. When we were going to fly, we would have left Zihua on June 1 and arrived on Tuesday the 4th, so this just means we are leaving Zihua 6 or 7 days earlier than planned, and arriving home on the same day as planned, or 1 day later. Not such a huge change in plans after all!

Good luck once again to everyone with a CAR STORY.

--
Linda from Canada
check out my books at www.livingthedreaminmexico.com AND please have a look at www.cookingwithclaudiainzihuatanejo.blogspot.com as well as www.albertoinzihuatanejo.blogspot.com

more on the the CAR STORY

by Esteban, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 12:27 (4965 days ago) @ Linda from Canada

I am still on an FM3 which expires on Aug. 18 when I am in MN. I'm driving back to MN in May/June. Returning to Z in Sept. with my car with the permit still on the windshield, Immigration here in Z told be no problem as there is a 55 day day grace period to renew...in this case get my new Visa. The immigration office again said no problem about the car. I am to go to Lazaro C with the renewal papers and get the new papers to keep my US plated car legal. Now you have me wondering if I'll get my car back across the border in September. hahahaha.
On my entry into MX this past August at Nuevo Laredo I was flagged through the interior crossing point without a stop or questions. I'm hoping this will happen again. B-)

more on the the CAR STORY

by Atlanta Dave @, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 18:06 (4964 days ago) @ Esteban

When I tried to convert my FM3 to a resedente temporal last Dec., I had read on-line about the 55 day grace period. Unfortunately, when I got to Immigration, they told me this was not correct and that I should have renewed 30 days prior to the expiration date. This led to many fines and lashes with wet noodles, plus multiple visits to Immigration to get the whole thing ironed out. Bottom line: I would recommend that you begin your FM3 renewal process 30 days BEFORE expiration if you want to avoid about 20 hours of sitting around the Immigration office. Just sayin'.

more on the the CAR STORY

by Esteban, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 18:42 (4964 days ago) @ Atlanta Dave

Thanks for your reply. I asked this very question at the immigration office. I had a Mex-Am friend with me to translate. I was assured that the 55 day grace period applied. I pushed on this point and she stood her ground. She said as long as I got my passport stamped with an exit date...and then of course with a reentry date in September the Aduana in Nuevo Laredo would not have a problem with my FM3 date. So...I'm going with her word...and still agree with you. Jajajajajajajaja. I can't be here in July. Business in El Norte. I figure the worst that can happen is that I have to start all over with new paperwork. :omg:

more on the the CAR STORY

by Tess, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 19:02 (4964 days ago) @ Esteban

I figure the worst that can happen is that I have to start all over with new paperwork. :omg:

Be aware that under the new immigration rules you can only start the process in your home country at the Mexican Consulate, NOT here.
Because the new rules are still being interpreted I would be very wary of not being here in my renewal period.

more on the the CAR STORY

by Esteban, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 19:12 (4964 days ago) @ Tess

Thank you. I did my current paperwork at the MX Consulate 10 minutes from my house in MN. Hahahahaha. I took them the required paperwork. They processed it and I had my provisional visa with photo taken at the office in my hand in less than an hour. When I got to Z in Aug. immigration handed me my FM3 within an hour. SLICK! But...IT'S MEXICO....land that I love...stand beside her.. and pay her the time and money for the privilege to be here. :vivamexico:

more on the the CAR STORY

by LadyM in Zihua, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 20:16 (4964 days ago) @ Esteban

No truth was ever spoken as well as that last sentence. Enjoyed reading it.

Avatar

more on the the CAR STORY

by Linda from Canada @, Zihua and Grand Marais, Manitoba, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 20:20 (4964 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Totally agree.

--
Linda from Canada
check out my books at www.livingthedreaminmexico.com AND please have a look at www.cookingwithclaudiainzihuatanejo.blogspot.com as well as www.albertoinzihuatanejo.blogspot.com

more on the the CAR STORY

by Canadian Rainbirds ⌂ @, Victoria BC and Zihuatanejo, Wednesday, April 17, 2013, 23:25 (4964 days ago) @ Linda from Canada

Hi Linda; Just for curiosity was your car built in Japan or otherwise overseas? That was likely the problem.

A couple of years ago I was talking with someone in Z who had a Suzuki with old plates on it He told me that he tried to get a permanent import but couldn't because it was made in Japan. He had bought the car particularly to tow to Mexico and leave it there. If he had bought the identical Chevy Tracker there wouldn't have been a problem. Identical vehicles, just depended where the parts were assembled!

On a similar note there are quite a few US built vehicles, cars as well as motorhomes, that cannot be imported to Canada because they cannot be made to match the Canadian regulations.

Gotta love the paper pushers! :beatwall:

Avatar

more on the the CAR STORY

by Linda from Canada @, Zihua and Grand Marais, Manitoba, Thursday, April 18, 2013, 07:55 (4964 days ago) @ Canadian Rainbirds

I don't know if in Japan or not, but according to the North American Free Trade Agreement (dah..that would be NAFTA, Linda), only vehicles made in Canada or the US can be permanently imported into Mexico. If your VIN begins with numbers, NAFTA says ok. If it begins with letters, NO. The amparo that I mentioned allows for vehicles with VINS that begin with letters to be permanently imported...except for those that begin with "K". I assume (could be wrong) that the "K" means made in Korea. Mine begins with "J" so maybe Japan is correct. But as I said, we evidently can't rely on this amparo since it could be over-ruled in the near future and then we would be back at square one...not worth the gamble for me.
If we had known about this NAFTA stuff, we would have bought an appropriate vehicle to bring here to Zihua, instead of the X Trail, although we are very happy with it. One of our friends is in a worse pickle. His VIN begins with "K". It's a Kia. There is no way it can stay...ever.

More than you wanted to know, right Art? Me too!

--
Linda from Canada
check out my books at www.livingthedreaminmexico.com AND please have a look at www.cookingwithclaudiainzihuatanejo.blogspot.com as well as www.albertoinzihuatanejo.blogspot.com

more on the the CAR STORY

by Lee@98223, Thursday, April 18, 2013, 10:29 (4964 days ago) @ Linda from Canada

No wonder that I saw no Kias or Hyundais there last winter.

Avatar

more on the the CAR STORY

by Linda from Canada @, Zihua and Grand Marais, Manitoba, Thursday, April 18, 2013, 12:03 (4964 days ago) @ Lee@98223

There are a few here. There is no problem importing them on a TIP- temporary import certificate; you just can't PERMANENTLY import them and put Mexican plates on them. The problem is arising from the new immigration laws that move previous holders of FM3's to RESIDENTE PERMANENTE. You can't be a permanent resident with a temporary vehicle. Either nationalize it (permanently import & put Mex plates on) or take it out of the country. We just can't be permanent and temporary at the same time- which actually makes a lot of sense.

--
Linda from Canada
check out my books at www.livingthedreaminmexico.com AND please have a look at www.cookingwithclaudiainzihuatanejo.blogspot.com as well as www.albertoinzihuatanejo.blogspot.com

NAFTA and your car's VIN

by devney @, Thursday, April 18, 2013, 22:34 (4963 days ago) @ Linda from Canada

if your VIN starts with 1, 4 or 5 then it comes from the states
if your VIN starts with 2 then it comes from Canada
if your VIN starts with 3 then it comes from Mexico

any of those cars can be imported (of course you don't need to import a mexican made car into mexico) otherwise it doesn't meet the NAFTA rule and so it probably can't be imported into Mexico.

more on the the CAR STORY

by Atlanta Dave @, Friday, April 19, 2013, 11:06 (4963 days ago) @ Esteban

I wish you luck! It seems to me that Immigration changes their story depending on the phase of the moon or the roll of the dice. Please let the board know how it works out for you; its always interesting to hear the latest on how the rules are being interpreted (or garbled). By the way, after having the FM3 for 5 years, my little mistake prevented me from converting to permanent resident, and I had to start the clock over again and be a "temporary resident" for 4 more years. Judging by the "temporary vs. permanent' discussion about the legal status of cars, this may be a stroke of good luck, at least for a few more years when the rules may change yet again.

more on the the CAR STORY

by LadyM in Zihua, Friday, April 19, 2013, 20:35 (4962 days ago) @ Atlanta Dave

I figured that might happen. All of it is up for change every year or so.

more on the the CAR STORY

by Lisette, Sunday, April 21, 2013, 21:03 (4960 days ago) @ Linda from Canada

We are having EXACTLY the same problem. We imported an older Toyota in November, and then my status changed in February (I wasn't aware that this was going to happen until then). You'd think someone could have said something in November...

Apparently some are getting a permenent residency, and others a temporary residency. Those with a permenant residency now have illegal cars...

I'm back in the states now, and the car is still in Mexico. I'll deal with this when I get back. Maybe they'll have it all figured out by then.


www.chulavidaplayablanca.webs.com