Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Katie Liz, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 09:44 (4741 days ago)

Hola.

I'm new to the forum so please forgive me if this topic has been discussed, but when I searched I couldn't find anything more recent than 2007 on the topic.

We are coming in March for a week and want to rent a car to head over to Troncones and be free to go back and forth all week.

Friends in Troncones tell me as of about a year ago the car rentals are adding a mandatory insurance of about $20 a day to the quoted price already agreed upon. I have always waived this because I have an American Express card that already has this coverage.

What's your experiences? Any suggestions? Best agencies to work with to get an honest quote? We might still rent but it would be nice to know the true total cost before we commit.

Gracias!

Katie Liz

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Canadian Rainbirds ⌂ @, Victoria BC and Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 09:58 (4741 days ago) @ Katie Liz

Unless your credit card company uses a Mexican insurance underwriter (doubtful) your credit card insurance will NOT be valid in Mexico. ALL of us who drive our own vehicles to Mexico MUST purchase Mexican insurance.

You do not want to drive in Mexico without good insurance. In the event of an accident you may be jailed until you can prove financially able to pay for all damages and/or injuries. An insurance policy will do that, and an adjuster may well respond to the accident scene. Police do NOT assign blame: that is done by a Judge at a later date.

HINT: use your digital camera or video camera to take pictures of all sides of the vehicle before you leave the rental agency especially if there is any damage, even tiny rock chips or scratches. Let the staff see what you are doing.

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Gringo Viejo @, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 10:40 (4741 days ago) @ Katie Liz

Some credit cards (my Capitol One Visa, for example) will honor the collision/comprehesive insurance that goes with the card BUT, a VERY BIG BUT, you will have to pay the repair costs (which may be inflated and you will have protest that to your card company) and then submit the receipts for reimbursement.

LIABILITY: Herta used to give a liability policy free with their contract but it had a dollar limitatin (???). Now the issue is: will the police honor the contract as a liability policy? It could get nasty as pointed out in other posts. Also, Hertz got a reputation as the company in Z that had employees that were making unauthorized charges to customers' credit cards. UGH!

My bottom line: We used Eurocar and paid the insurance a couple of years ago and slept like a baby vs. they years I used my credit card and Hertz liability coverage when I always worried about a problem. TAKE the insurance and SLEEP well, my friends! BTW on line reservations (make a print-out) has also gotten us the best rates.

Avatar

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by grappa135, Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 11:08 (4741 days ago) @ Gringo Viejo

Earlier this year I had some friends visiting from Australia. They had booked a Eurocar plus Insurance through Orbitz. When they went to collect the car, at the Zihua Airport agency, they were informed that the Orbitz insurance would not cover the car and they would need to buy insurance at $20 a day from the agency. This they grudgingly did, and had to claim a refund from Orbitz on their return to Australia.

--
Graham Felipe'

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Gringo Viejo @, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 11:26 (4741 days ago) @ grappa135

In fact I was assured at the counter in downtown Ixtapa that the best rental rate was at the counter (I checked and it was! So rented there and took the insurance even I was told I could use my credit card for the collision/comp but had to buy the liability. I bit the bullet and slept well during the five days up/back to Patzcuaro. A loverly place by the way---and inexpensive with real Mexican culture not the beach "tourista" experience.

Avatar

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Pelicano, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 10:59 (4741 days ago) @ Katie Liz

there was an excellent article on this very issue that I have posted here before, but of course now I can't find it. The bottom line is a compilation of what some others have posted here. Your card may well cover the extra comp costs or more,and it's a good idea to have the issuer send you a letter to that effect, and get in translated if possible (I have one from Allianz, insurer on my master card). The catch-22 is that although you may be covered, it depends where you are, how bad the accident is, the attitude of the other guy, and the attitude and or comprehension of the cops.
A friend of mine had an accident in Cabo a couple of years ago, no problem, card took care of it all (Platinum Amex). But if you're in the middle of nowhere, you may possibly find yourself sitting as Viejo describes.

Some rentals have basic liability included in the rental, others may insist you take their full package. Anyway, it comes down to your own personal risk aversion. I have rented in Zihua, La Paz, and Loreto, sometimes paying up, sometimes skating on what my cards offer...:peace:

Avatar

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Malury @, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 11:51 (4741 days ago) @ Pelicano

The 'mandatory insurance" is a scam. The AX cards and other credit cards do indeed cover the CDW in Mexico. This scam started with a few car rental agencys a few years ago... now its rampant. If you ask how much does it cost to rent a car, your are told one price, then when you show up are told it will be double the price, that is dishonest. In actual fact the CDW your credit card has is better coverage than what the CDW sold to you in Mexico. Any accident in Mexico can result in drama, does not matter what your car rental agreement says about insurance.
As a travel agent, I have arranged many car rentals in Mexico. I also rent cars in Mexico myself. I have spent a lot of time researching this "new" development. The only mandatory insurance in Mexico is the TPL (third party liability) and that insurance by law must be included already in the rate quoted. I posted a week ago if anyone had used Green Motion, a new car rental in Zihua. No answer, I emailed the company to find out its policies, and they too, insist on quoting one rate then tacking on the 20.00 per day for CDW. Their policy page in my computer says 12.00 CDW in Zihua. Funny they came up with the "20.00" per day rate.
I recently rented a car in Cabo, Avis, I got their office to send in writing that they will not tack on the insurance. They even went so far as to acknowledge the dishonesty of other car rental companies practices. They assured me they don't do this scam.
I am looking into filing a formal complaint with the Mexican Tourism board on this illegal business practice.

Avatar

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Pelicano, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 12:04 (4741 days ago) @ Malury

As I say, see how it all works out for you in a little town somewhere, the local cop will bend over backwards for you, I am sure. That's the bottom line, how lucky do you feel.

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Gringo Viejo @, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 12:28 (4741 days ago) @ Malury

I once reserved on line and printed out the reservtion. When the counter in Z said I had to purchase insurance I just showed them the print out and they dropped the subject. Note: Be advised if you buy CDW from the rental company then your card will not cover you. I doubt ANY card covers TPL and not sure it is covered by all contracts (Hertz plainly prints it on the contract).

In any case it is a crap shoot when you get in trouble in timbuktu. You are at the mercy of the local authorities, period. As said elsewhere, you can be detained until a judge rules on the case, which can be days! This just me, I would hesitate to pay a mordida if a local on site attorney suggests I should.

BTW if a rental agencey EVER tries to tack damage onto your card just protest it immediately. They must follow a very specific set of procedures (and so do you) to settle the case. I have done this twice over the years and the rental agency did not follow correct procedure and I (my credit card company) did NOT have to pay, period.

Avatar

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Malury @, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 13:12 (4741 days ago) @ Gringo Viejo

Last March I brought in a print out from American Express stating quite clearly it covered Mexico. I also had a previous rental paperwork from the SAME car company (Europcar) that even said in THEIR paperwork that the CDW was not mandatory. You would think that would do it right? wrong
They just shrugged and I left without a car. I also asked to speak to the manager, he was called on the cell phone and he refused to speak to me. I am sure the agents that handle your check in are under strict orders from above to charge the extra fee no matter what.

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Paulf @, Mount Sterling, Ky 40353, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 14:55 (4741 days ago) @ Malury

Hertz was really bad before- don't know now. When we returned a car after a week, the attendant could not find any scratches that were not noted on the inspection sheet and at that point he saw some dust underneath the car- the attendant reached under the engine and got some oil on his fingers. I was told that it would cost $200 US to fix the leak. I had no choice but pay it. I notified AMEX as soon as I got back to Pacifica by email and was told to keep all the paperwork to submit when we got home. To make a long story short- the rent a car headquarters in MC did not verify the damage and a couple of months later the charge on my AMEX Card was reimbursed.
We have not rented a car since and found it is cheaper to use a taxi.

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Katie Liz, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 22:13 (4741 days ago) @ Malury

Thank you Malury! Let's see what happens in the next few months, but I hope these international businesses get so publicly shamed that they knock it off. Meanwhile hopefully the loss of business costs them the difference they make scamming their customers.

Car Rental Helpful Article (link)

by Bailey, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 16:39 (4741 days ago) @ Pelicano

Avatar

Car Rental Helpful Article (link)

by Pelicano, Tuesday, November 26, 2013, 21:13 (4741 days ago) @ Bailey

Yep,that's the one I couldn't find on my laptop,thanks...

Car Rental Helpful Article (link)

by igotnews4u, Wednesday, November 27, 2013, 07:33 (4740 days ago) @ Pelicano

We have rented a car every time we've come to MX. We buy the full coverage and take pictures. I have never had a problem and consider it part of renting in MX. I have looked at the Visa policy, but would not want the hassle if something happened. I'm on vacation and have no time for fussing when I return the car or if there's an accident. I use Alamo on the pacific side.

Crazy tidbit, When we were in Cancun, we were welcomed with a beer at the rental company. Go figure?

Avatar

Car Rental Helpful Article (link)

by Pelicano, Wednesday, November 27, 2013, 10:25 (4740 days ago) @ igotnews4u

Classic!

Car Rental Helpful Article (link)

by JohnnyJ ⌂ @, Oly, Wednesday, November 27, 2013, 19:49 (4740 days ago) @ Pelicano

Great thread. Thank you.
Last March in Cabo. After being told there was no liability insurance on the Avis car and I was required to have it, I showed them clearly (in the fine print) the govt regulated mandatory liability amount of 650 000 (I think) pesos was included in the rental price.
I had downloaded this from the rental contract when I made my reservation online. Wow! surprise to them. Can I make a copy por favor. Well, yes, but it is your company, curious you do not have access to this information.....

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by mdirkm, Sunday, December 22, 2013, 14:07 (4715 days ago) @ Katie Liz

I have read all of these posts and I'm still a little confused. Is there any such thing as zero liability insurance for a rental car? I only want one for a couple of days so I'm not trying to save money.

Mandatory Insurance for Car Rentals?

by Gringo Viejo @, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Sunday, December 22, 2013, 17:16 (4715 days ago) @ mdirkm

BUT THE LIABILITZY INSURance!!!!! Anyway, it is THE INSURANCE YOU DEFINITELY WANT! It does nothing to protect the rental company but covers YOU IN CASE you are involved in an accident. Even if you are plainly not at fault you will be held until that is decided by the authorities that you are not to blame. If you are fault free you may be released but not in what you would consider a timely manner. If you are at fault and you don't have liability insurance then bend over, grab the back of your knees and kiss you a*s goodbye cause you are going in the pokey until the judicial does its thing and then YOU WILL PAY thru the nose before you are released and the American gov't can't and won't do a d**n thing. GET THE LIABILITY INSURANCE AT LEASET!!! EVEN IF YOU THINK THERE IS LIABILITY INCLUDED IN THE CONTRACT.


The collision/comp insurance makes sure the rental company for any damage to their care.