Any thoughts on the best All Inclusive

We've been owners at the Pacifica since 1986. For the last 6 years or so, we've been doing a non-AI for the first 5 days & AI for the next 9 of our vacation. Their AI gives you a choice of restaurants, with a show nightly. During the daytime they have activities going on from about 9:00am till 5:00pm, They also have special programs & activities for the smaller kids during the day where the parents need not be there.
Is the AI good? Breakfast definitely! Dinners, some nights yes, other nights it's just a regular buffet. They do have certain nights during the week where they'll have special dinners at some of their restaurants (bar-b-ques, Italian night, Mexican fiesta on Mondays. etc.), these nights are good. Lunch can be had in either the restaurant (buffet) and/or beach (off a menu), your choice. Lunches are good.

We have stayed at the El Presidente (now Holiday Inn) in the past & utilized their AI. I think the Pacifica is better. Other places in the area, I cannot comment on.