article about Fonatur development in La Barra
Well, I'd say you've got it just exactly in the reverse. To the ever ironic frustration of my family up north, my business (a hotel prepared to cater to an international clientele) could possibly benefit from such a development- though it would require a change of focus, promotion and staff (me for one - as I would have no desire to remain in La Barra if the local community and the pristine nature of the ecology of the lagoon is destroyed).
However, the impact on the local fishermen community - my neighbors and friends of 15 years - would be devastating. You seem to have the idea 100s of families would be 'lifted out of poverty'. That sounds good on paper. Only it has nothing do to with the reality of the situation. A mega-project drives the poor local community into far worse situations...especially in an area such as La Barra where presently a poor family can live quite well in this climate and this cohesive community.
I have no idea how you figure that they would be 'lifted out of poverty' considering their livelihood would be destroyed, their tax rates on their homes would most probably drive them out of the area, they have no interest in the kinds of jobs 'promised' (I say promised because it is well demonstrated these jobs do not go to the local poor community in reality. And even if they did, the people would have a lower quality of life tied to such low paid jobs with higher costs of living).
Most of the people of La Barra, full of life, creative intelligence and independent personalities have fewer than 6 years of formal education and no interest in becoming the low paid servants of the wealthy class who would be driving them out of their homes and businesses with a very lopsided resource base. They like being business owners, home owners - relatively poor but with the possibility of helping their next generation rise above limitations while remaining the sovereign determinants in their own community in La Barra...in a future they themselves may design while they develop their own economic pathway.
This is actually forming and what they are fomenting is far superior to what Fonatur offers. It includes developing sustainable eco-tourism owned by the local community, sustainable fish farming and more. This is a future with some dignity and much more power and it's the one they want...not what Fonatur is trying to slide past them as 'Economic Development' when what it really represents is stealing their land, livelihood, community and lifestyle - (while they make big bucks for those behind it) trading it for something that shamefully doesn't reach the ankles of what is currently lived by the local community.
Fonatur has done this before to local communities. The difference is that the people of Barra are not naive to the truths behind the buzz words and rhetoric. They may have little formal education but they are not stupid and they are not without information.
It is well known that those who fill the jobs created by this mess come from elsewhere...not from fishermen communities. Staff is imported. Most locals have no interest in trading their current lives for that type of situation even if they were trainable for that kind of life. I happen to know this from having lived among them for more than 15 years with close relationships with my neighbors. This is what they tell me - what THEY say. They would like to be left alone by Fonatur and ideally to have their government's support to develop a sustainable eco-tourism project here in the home they have worked for generations. They don't want a mega-project, believe me.
You might want to review the information in the numerous studies which have by now clearly shown that mega-developments of this kind displace local communities which are driven into far worse conditions of poverty as a result of the development. Besides the economic difficulties they also suffer from the loss of their roots, ties to the land and their communities and the cultures therein. It is well documented that people in such displacement situations often fall into many psychological difficulties after this displacement including much higher rates of divorce, depression, alcoholism, drug addiction and suicide.
I'll be a survivor which ever way it goes...probably I could do better financially to support it, laughably enough. That doesn't interest me. I oppose it because it is totally wrong from every point of view I can imagine...but especially more than anything else...it is a terrible prospect for my neighbors, my community of 15 years - a small close knit community of people who are my friends, whose chldren I have had my small part in helping to raise as a neighbor, madrina and the director of the Children's Library and for whom I want only the best.
Complete thread:
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - Laura, 2011-05-14, 09:19
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - Laura, 2011-05-14, 10:08
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - kate, 2011-05-14, 10:12
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - ZihuaRob, 2011-05-14, 10:42
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - MXCDN, 2011-05-15, 13:06
- already onboard - ZihuaRob, 2011-05-15, 13:36
- AWESOME!!! - MXCDN, 2011-05-15, 15:10
- already onboard - ZihuaRob, 2011-05-15, 13:36
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - TheDon, 2011-05-14, 18:23
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - JeffMN, 2011-05-14, 18:38
- self determination - ZihuaRob, 2011-05-14, 19:26
- New Muelle is a scam? - Harry, 2011-05-14, 20:21
- New Muelle is a scam? - Harriet, 2011-05-14, 22:16
- New Muelle is a scam? - Harry, 2011-05-14, 20:21
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - Laura, 2011-05-15, 18:32
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-05-15, 18:40
- Laura - Lee@98223, 2011-05-14, 22:36
- Laura - Laura, 2011-05-15, 06:15
- article about Fonatur development in La Barra - Laura, 2011-05-14, 10:08

