Coming for New Years ! Recommendations please

I am not sure how to make reservations at Catalina for the New Years Eve Dinner - i sent them an email asking for a reservation for 4. I will do it again in December. I will check the message board website for a good fishing charter company. One year we booked thru a hotel.We went out on a charter , everyone drew a number and our number was last - we never even got a chance to throw a line in boo hoo : we were unsure how it worked and there was another family and they had 2 kids - they literally took up all the time as their numbers were drawn first and by the time our number came up it was time to come back to port. Live and learn - any charter co's you all would recommend to take out a family of 3 or 4 ? thanks