LAURA, WHERE ARE YOU?
I've been away (family wedding and reunion) but finally checked up on things here. These are worrying times indeed for La Barra. For a long time we've known this was coming and now it is here and happening. Luckily there are many good people working and have been working to protect Barra de Potosi.
In your question it's not toally clear to which part of the development you refer. I will assume you refer to the specific part of the development referred to in the start of this thread by the company who owns Sol Ixtapa. The development is apparently called - the "Desarrollo Eco-Turistico Residential Laud" and is located in the area called the 'Puente' between Valentin and the lagoon of Potosi and on the southern border of the overall Fonatur development plan encompassing Barra de Potosi, Cruise ship pier, lagoon dragging, marina, bridge building, hotels golf courses etc.
This development - now begun - is the one responsible for the construction of the road which blocks the flow of water between the two estuary systems - the lagoon of Valentin, Petatlan River and the lagoon of Potosi. The result of this blockage if not remedied will be the death of the lagoon of Potosi...and thus serious negative mpact on the life and livehood of the community of Barra de Potosi and the entire ecosystem of the area. Kind of a big oversight.
I am still out of town and have only just now come upon a 50 page report to Semarnat describing this 'Laud' development plan. This is a development of about 104 plus hectares including 50% to be sold as private residences, a commercial zone, hotels and golf courses. It is described as 'ecological' and claiming to be in congruence with all the federal ordinances pertaining to ecological protections.
ok...that sounds good maybe kind of (not really). But then I start to pay attention to some details and questions arise. Well...ok, I had questions arising from the first meeting with their rep that occurred in early May when the blocking of the lagoon waters was first noticed.
When you read this report, the words sound good and all the necessary buzz words are included ('Eco-logical, protect flora and fauna, congruence with regulations etc). But then you look at the reality of what is actually happening and you start to notice huge gaping holes big as universes. The building of the road and the blocking of the waters was the first one...and is significant enough. It has been 'promised' that this will be fixed with a small bridge. Will that be enough? Will it even be done? So far...waiting to see.
But as I read this report, other questions arise for me. For example: more than 50 hectares of private residences and two hotels and golf courses and no residual black waters treatment plant of any kind...? each lot is expected to provide their own private septic. I'm not an architect but I know enough to ask, up to what kind of density is that reasonable in a wetland zone? I didn't see any mention of what the source of potable would be.
Encompassing 104 plus hectares of area now home to hundreds of species of birds and other wildlife and just over 2 hectares slated to be devoted to the protection of wildlife in one iguanario and one bird house. That would be 102 hectares of species displacement onto 2 hectares of mostly iguanario (I hate to say it but the word 'Delphinario was also mentioned). In describing the road work it was termed 'maintenance' of an existing road when in fact there has been (photographed here) construction of a densely compacted new road on top of a path resulting in far higher impact than implied or dealt with in the report.
There was no reference whatsoever to the clearing of protected mangroves which does violate Federal Law. This is a pretty massive project that is planned to be developed over a ten year period. IMO from what I have seen and read so far, it talks the Eco-talk but doesn't have 'Eco' reality behind it. Far to the contrary and par for the course is the slicker style of a more greenish gentrified, 'slip in the back door' kind of ecocide. I hope to be proven wrong.
But meanwhile, right now (and with construction barely begun) the villagers are concerned - to put it lightly - to be watching the impending death of the lagoon of Potosi already from the get-go.
I'd say there are pretty much zero people in the village who feel favorably about this development AS it is being done from the start... (well ok, there may be two or three people in the village community who don't care and naively think they will come out ahead selling their holdings). Perhaps there are some along the beach whose vision of the future may be more in line with that of Desarrollo Residential Laud designers. No need to mention initials and these folks are well in the minority.
Light shined on these things is a good thing. People communicating their opinions about it to the appropriate addresses provided is an important part of that light. Of course many layers of work must be done to have any hope of minimizing nagative impact and keeping development congruent with environmental laws (in reality - not only on paper). Luckily, many layers of work are being done. The energetic, caring response of the message board community is an important and well appreciated part of the effort to protect la Barra.
My only contact with the Sol Ixtapa group was with the representative who was at the first community meeting in La Barra. I personally was negatively impressed with his unresponsive and disrespectful attitude toward the Barra community at that meeting. Now I am negatively impressed with the report I am still making my way through because of the gap between what the words say and what known realities on the ground show. Let's hope that with information and effective communication the future will show an improved scenario and a course more true to the ecological principals any future buyer of an 'Eco-development' will want to see as reality.
Complete thread:
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 17:15
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 17:27
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - katherine, 2011-06-04, 18:17
- corrupt politicians and greedy developers - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-04, 19:21
- corrupt politicians and greedy developers - allen, 2011-06-06, 01:03
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - HolyMole, 2011-06-06, 13:09
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - allen, 2011-06-07, 01:52
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - Lee@98223, 2011-06-07, 22:26
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - allen, 2011-06-08, 00:14
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - Lee@98223, 2011-06-07, 22:26
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - allen, 2011-06-07, 01:52
- The Monkey Wrench Gang - HolyMole, 2011-06-06, 13:09
- corrupt politicians and greedy developers - allen, 2011-06-06, 01:03
- corrupt politicians and greedy developers - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-04, 19:21
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - judi in OKlahoma, 2011-06-04, 20:42
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 22:38
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-04, 22:59
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-05, 01:43
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-05, 09:00
- Thanks - ElAleman, 2011-06-05, 09:59
- Thanks - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-05, 11:12
- Your commitment - ElAleman, 2011-06-05, 11:48
- Thanks - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-05, 11:12
- Thanks - ElAleman, 2011-06-05, 09:59
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-05, 09:00
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-05, 01:43
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-04, 22:59
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 22:38
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - Fran, 2011-06-05, 15:13
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - Dave, 2011-06-05, 16:17
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - katherine, 2011-06-04, 18:17
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Timmac, 2011-06-04, 17:36
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 18:21
- Back atcha! - JeffMN, 2011-06-05, 00:02
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - frostbite, 2011-06-05, 09:10
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - kate, 2011-06-05, 09:45
- Don't Give Up Hope - Barraster, 2011-06-05, 21:15
- Wrong contact - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-06, 09:00
- Wrong contact - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-06, 18:39
- asses & assets (cont'd) - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-06, 19:01
- asses & assets (cont'd) - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-06, 19:37
- asses & assets (cont'd) - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-06, 20:14
- asses & assets (cont'd) - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-06, 19:37
- asses & assets (cont'd) - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-06, 19:01
- Wrong contact - Fran, 2011-06-06, 20:42
- Wrong contact - Craig Scheiner, 2011-06-06, 23:00
- Wrong contact - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-06, 18:39
- Wrong contact - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-06, 09:00
- Send this report and photos to news outlets . . . - Abigail, 2011-06-06, 12:12
- Send this report and photos to news outlets . . . - Abigail, 2011-06-06, 12:13
- LAURA, WHERE ARE YOU? - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-07, 16:09
- LAURA, WHERE ARE YOU? - islandgirl, 2011-06-07, 20:25
- LAURA, WHERE ARE YOU? - Laura, 2011-06-07, 22:12
- taking matters into your own hands - islandgirl, 2011-06-07, 23:17
- Vote with your pocketbook= - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-08, 10:44
- think with your brain - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-08, 11:16
- think with your brain - Vancouvertony, 2011-06-08, 12:18
- think with your brain - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-08, 12:41
- think with your brain - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-09, 10:54
- think with your brain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-06-09, 17:26
- think with your brain - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-09, 10:54
- think with your brain - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-08, 12:41
- think with your brain - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-09, 10:39
- think with your brain - Vancouvertony, 2011-06-08, 12:18
- think with your brain - ZihuaRob, 2011-06-08, 11:16
- taking matters into your own hands - Zmon01, 2011-06-08, 22:09
- Vote with your pocketbook= - Gringo Viejo, 2011-06-08, 10:44
- taking matters into your own hands - islandgirl, 2011-06-07, 23:17
- Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi is shut down by PROFEPA! - Laura, 2011-06-08, 15:29
- The Sol Ixtapa Threat to Laguna Potosi - Photos - ElAleman, 2011-06-04, 17:27

