Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole
Most interesting article. I think I have the jist of it, but the translations are a bit wonky sometimes. Sounds like the archaeologist is annoying the villagers. Could be an anthropologist, but likely an archaeologist. Archaeologist says he/gov't bought all the land. The villagers say it was an illegal sale. Archaeologist is trying to protect the integrity of the site, which is a huge undertaking. The villagers are trying to plant gardens and crops.
This is a 'refer to Solomon' question I think.
If Arch. sites are plowed, dug up or otherwise disturbed, all knowledge about the site can be lost. Happens here all the time. Developers go in with excavators, claim afterwards that they didn't know and didn't see the skulls and stone tools rolling around. Then the archaeologists are hired to go in and literally sift through the mountains of midden left piled up. This salvage operation is just that, salvaging artifacts and human remains, often very damaged. These things, taken out of the context of the site itself, tell you very little about what was happening there. Hamburger Archaeology, I call it. No science at all. Properly studied, a site can tell you so much about the people that occupied it. Health, diet, local weather, society, pastimes, lifestyle, flora, fauna,.....Government here has Heritage Conservation Act, which makes it illegal to harm an archaeological site, regardless of whether you know it is one or not. However, on the other hand, developers can just apply for an 'Alteration permit' that allows them to legally carry on with the destruction. It seems to be part of the whole colonization mentality. Destroy all evidence of the First Nations people's use and occupation, and then you can carry on living on the land that has been stolen from them and getting rich from the resources of that land, while they live in third world conditions right here in good old Canada. When I sing the national anthem, I really mean 'home & NATIVE land!!! And for those of you not familiar with British Columbia, most of it has never been subject to treaties with the First Nations, so it is truy stolen land. Natives have taken this to court and the courts have ruled First Nations do hold aboriginal title to the land, but the gov't doesn't like that and continues to stall and deny it. Only a small part of the NE corner of the province and some very small areas around the SW coast have been covered by treaties. But I digress....
The villagers need to use the land that they've lived on for generations, and very likely inherited from the original inhabitants of the site. They need land to survive, and some should be made available to them, the closer the better, IF the Arch site is to be saved. Quite possibly, the villagers could move back once excavations are finished, but this could be many years.
Which brings me to this thought. Having been to La Chole in March, I was amazed at the extent of this site. It is truly incredible, and that's only what can be seen so far! I remember reading before my visit, that at first they didn't think this site was of much importance. That seemed to change when the pyramids and particularly the ball court were found. From what I saw, this will prove to be a major site, right up there with other more famous sites in Mexico and central America. Done properly, this could be one of the biggest attractions of the area and really pump up the visibility of Zihua and surrounding area, as well as be a major boost to the economy.
Somebody better get to La Chole in the meantime, and do a little peacemaking! With some common sense, this could work out to be fantastic for everyone involved.
Oh, one more thing, local people should be hired to work at the site. It doesn't take a lot to train field assistants, but they do need training (maybe about a week long course done right there on the gorund). These assistants will then understand too, why the archaeologist is flipping out over planting, and can help to make this situation less volatile by translating to the other villagers from archaeologists language into villagers language. And the field assistants will have new knowledge and appreciation of the site they are working on. I think Adnan could skip the training 'tho. I'd hire him in a minute! This kind of local knowledge can be invaluable, altho' I've heard locals aren't included in the work being done. That was a huge mistake. That's why I figure it's an archaeologist. Anthropologist not likely to do something so ethnocentric.
Complete thread:
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-01, 13:13
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - Sharkboy, 2011-07-01, 15:40
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - islandgirl, 2011-07-01, 16:19
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - Donnyboy, 2011-07-01, 17:58
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - islandgirl, 2011-07-01, 20:39
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - Donnyboy, 2011-07-01, 17:58
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - islandgirl, 2011-07-01, 16:19
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - islandgirl, 2011-07-01, 16:12
- Missing artifacts - Dione, 2011-07-02, 16:39
- Missing artifacts - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-02, 16:59
- Eminent Domain - Dione, 2011-07-02, 17:02
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-02, 17:12
- Eminent Domain - Dione, 2011-07-05, 16:04
- Eminent Domain - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-05, 18:30
- Eminent Domain - D-Loco, 2011-07-06, 00:52
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-06, 01:10
- Eminent Domain - frostbite, 2011-07-06, 08:46
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-06, 08:55
- THE POINT BEING... - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-06, 10:02
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-06, 08:55
- Eminent Domain - frostbite, 2011-07-06, 08:46
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-06, 01:10
- Eminent Domain - D-Loco, 2011-07-06, 00:52
- Eminent Domain - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-05, 18:30
- Eminent Domain - Dione, 2011-07-05, 16:04
- Eminent Domain - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-02, 17:12
- Eminent Domain - Dione, 2011-07-02, 17:02
- Missing artifacts - islandgirl, 2011-07-03, 00:55
- Missing artifacts - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-25, 13:29
- Missing artifacts - islandgirl, 2011-07-25, 15:45
- Missing artifacts - ZihuaRob, 2011-07-25, 13:29
- Missing artifacts - read this - islandgirl, 2011-07-08, 10:38
- Missing artifacts - LadyM in Zihua, 2011-07-02, 16:59
- Muy molestos los habitantes de La Chole - Sharkboy, 2011-07-01, 15:40

