interesting is an understatement
As always - valuable, to hear your perspective. I can't imagine that you would consider Fed and State police opening fire w AK 47s on unarmed student demonstrators to be an acceptable act. I hadn't been aware of this practice of hijacking busses etc. Of course, if they violated the law they should be legally stopped and processed properly but not gunned down by AK 47s on the spot, right? However, I always appreciate your insight and am most usually in agreement with you on these core issues pertaining to happenings around us in Guerrero so you gave me food for thought. Of course kidnapping busses is not conducive to gaining respect though it doesn't justify murder by the police.
I decided to check a bit further with some other teachers I know who also went to the state normal schools and who have visited the particular school in question to see what they would add as well.
The result seems to be a concurrence that the students are not evil...but misguided in their methods, bright but lacking an update to their ideology and curriculum (Chairman Mao...uuummm!...not exactly state of the art...even for the left) and certainly in need of some guidance. But this is not cause for a death sentence carried out without respect of the law by the police. Two separate issues and it would be a shame if one acts to cover the other.
I saw there was a report by Amnesty International condemning the government for it's responsibility in the murders of the demonstrators and calling for continued investigation into the matter. I don't assume you are in disagreement with the Amnesty International report though you clearly disapprove of the techniques of the students in calling attention to their issues. Disapproval of bus hijacking is certainly understandable.
It seems unfortunate that the political immaturity of the students (using bus hijacking and extortion to call attention to their issues as if Chairman Mao and Che Guevara were the best evolved examples of effective activism in the interests of the poor in the 21st century) were to result in a disposition of tolerance of the far greater wrong of the government opening fire with AK 47s on unarmed people.
I am in no way excusing the actions of the police. All the evidence I've seen implicates the Policías Ministeriales del Estado, who remind me of the corrupt old judiciales. But that needs to remain a separate issue. The so-called students do not need to clamor for justice because the entire country wants to see justice in this matter. The students do not need to continue extorting from people and hijacking buses and blocking roads. They are only compounding the problem, not resolving it.
The death of the gas station attendant is a result of whoever left the bomb. A videotape from the gas station reportedly shows two masked men leaving it then running to where the police were located. This would lend itself to the appearance it was placed there if not by the police themselves then by someone sheltered by the police. This video was on youtube for a short time when it was 'removed'.
I must have seen different videos. The ones I've seen clearly show protesters setting the fire at the gas pump while stealing gas for their molotov coctails. There was no bomb. That would appear to be another one of those myths the perredistas and ayotzinapenses are spreading.
This matter interests me foremost because I believe in the importance of education. Obviously freedom to develop education depends on basic safety of students and teachers. Light shed on an issue is a good thing so I thought to ask here for more info. The truth usually tends to be some third perspective encompassing and going beyond two apparently contradicting ones.
As always, thank you for your informative perspective Rob. It's been an interesting and enlightening several days for me...as I was out of the loop on this one till neighbors came door to door collecting food for the demonstrators.
I hope cooler heads will now prevail and there will be no further violence.
I hope they can update their curriculum to include state of the art study of nonviolent activism as part of a balanced curriculum - including all they will need as teachers in general so they will be able to do well in a fair placement exam in lieu of the problematic 'plazas'. It would be a shame if the concept of the school itself suffers for these details. To provide free education focused specifically for the poorest in the state in an 'internado' seems a good idea. Needs to be updated and implemented better apparently.
When I was young I didn't agree with Che's use of violence and the exportation of his idea of revolution. I don't condemn young folks today for idealizing him, but true students of political and social systems should easily see beneath the aura of false promises to the myth that makes up much of his legacy. Mao, ni hablar, in spite of the positive achievements attributed to his leadership, the guy is responsible for the destruction of millennia of Chinese culture and history. That's a pretty big oops!
Ayotzinapa has a notorious history in Guerrero. While some of our revered revolutionary figures went to this school, in the past decade or so the actions of the so-called students have been deplorable. Hijacking buses, blocking highways to steal gas and obtain involuntary "donations", harassing visitors and residents of our region. I'm all for education, too, and I've nothing against clamoring for social justice or better education or whatever. Heck, I don't even have any problems with communism, BUT I do have a problem when the actions of a few involve and affect detrimentally the larger population. In these difficult years for our tourism we do NOT need delinquents blocking our highways. There are supposed to be state and federal laws against this. But as you well know we have lots of lovely laws that are not enforced correctly or consistently.
Complete thread:
- plaza de los flojos...interesting group collecting food - Laura, 2012-01-13, 11:15
- interesting is an understatement - ZihuaRob, 2012-01-15, 15:06
- interesting is an understatement - LadyM in Zihua, 2012-01-15, 15:19
- interesting is an understatement - Laura, 2012-01-15, 21:26
- interesting is an understatement - Judemx, 2012-01-15, 23:03
- interesting is an understatement - Laura, 2012-01-15, 23:36
- interesting is an understatement - ZihuaRob, 2012-01-16, 09:53
- agenda of the so-called students - ZihuaRob, 2012-01-16, 10:15
- interesting is an understatement - Judemx, 2012-01-15, 23:03
- interesting is an understatement - ZihuaRob, 2012-01-15, 15:06

