the question remains...
Hijole! It seems we have this same tiresome “discussion” every year. With all due respect, Rob, your unchanging opinion is at best uninformed. You have never attended a volunteer meeting, never visited one of our schools, and have repeatedly declined invitations to participate on the advisory committee that makes all funding decisions. In fairness, you have explained that you are “too busy”.
This year’s corrections to your post would include:
In a good year we may build 2 or 3 three-room schools that typically serve a total of 250-300 students. All are legal schools in legal neighborhoods that either lack adequate schools, or have schools already overflowing with students and cannot accept more. These projects are in partnership with the City of Zihuatanejo, through their donations of building materials and labor. Not one peso has gone to a “squatter settlement” since 2004. And, our bright-eyed young scholars look much too innocent to be “lawbreakers”.
Apparently you trust that the City of Zihuatanejo is above using you and your cause for their own ends. You think because the government legalizes a squatter community that everything is okay with it. You aren't making the distinction that most of the long-time residents I know are making, folks who are fed up at seeing the government serve its own needs and go so far as to enlist the help of foreigners. Some of the good deeds you do are inevitably serving the ends of unscrupulous self-serving politicians, yet you appear completely unaware of this, though many if not most local citizens here are aware and see it plain as day, which is why I keep bringing the matter up. You may think getting your photo in the paper gives prestige to your cause, but posing next to Tico Fernández may not be as prestigious as you think.
According to the Zihuatanejo Director of Education, all 234 Zihua schools are under-funded and under-equipped; so we focus our limited funding, with the City’s direction, on the schools most in need . A significant portion of each year’s revenue does go for repair or expansion of older existing schools. The two repair projects your lovely wife, Lupita, brought to our attention were old schools in La Noria.
Impressive, you underscore and gloss over the problem in the same paragraph. I assure you my wife agrees with me 100%. And while I'm sure my friend and neighbor in charge of Educación Municipal means well, obviously local education is a disaster partially because of the points I am trying to address and would prefer to discuss instead of your defensive rationalizations for why you keep doing things the old way that we already know doesn't work. Yes, you are unquestionably providing much help and assistance and improving the quality of education where you can. I truly understand and appreciate that part. No complaints here. But I believe your assistance could go further if you took a larger view instead of continuing to do what is convenient for the government, who obviously isn't seriously interested in educating students in Guerrero or preparing them for anything beyond being menial laborers and domestic servants. I know you want better for them and that is why you do what you do. But with 200+ schools in our municipio (apparently we're counting the sierra and outlying communities though I don't know why) it is obvious that their current budget precludes anything resembling a serious education. Thus my original question.
Mexican parents will not allow their 3- to 8-year-old children to walk more than about 6 blocks to school; they do not consider it safe. Most mothers accompany their little kids even that short distance. I, like you, walked about a mile to my U.S. school, (you forgot to mention that it was uphill both ways). These are different times, a different place, and perhaps different circumstances.
I live practically next door to the community's oldest school and I watch this soap opera every morning. Again, you act like we are stuck in a time warp. In many places in Mexico children travel MUCH further to get to school. For example, the children from Las Gatas seem to have no problem crossing the bay to get to school. Local parents can adapt to the needs of their children if they truly wish them to get an education. It sounds to me like you're falling for their excuses, which sound strangely similar to the excuses the squatters used to use (though we're not discussing them).
Rob, I know you are concerned about squatter issues and the environment. So are we, and we believe our educational initiatives reflect our sensitivity to the quality of life in Zihuatanejo. After all, we live here too, (including the 5 Mexican educators on our committee). Should you choose to learn a bit more about what we are doing, or volunteer to help, I suspect you will discover that we are on the same page on most issues.
For now, on behalf of the 50+ Sailfest volunteers, the City of Zihuatanejo, Rotary International, the more than 200 local donating businesses, and our 4 international non-profit partners, I can only apologize for not meeting your personal standards.
Con amistad,
Lorenzo
Well, you're talking about one thing and I'm talking about another. It has nothing to do with my standards, which no local school will ever reach in my lifetime, and it really has very little to do with the squatters at this point since they've already won thanks to the help of some unscrupulous politicians who changed the laws to make landowners out of land thieves. It has to do with fixing what is so obviously broken instead of putting makeup on a terminally ill patient. I can only offer you some food for thought and hope you try it and digest it.
But thanks anyway for giving me your standard reply.
Complete thread:
- FRIDAY MEETING OF SAILFEST VOLUNTEERS - JACK, 2012-02-02, 09:08
- question about methodology - ZihuaRob, 2012-02-02, 09:46
- question about methodology - troya, 2012-02-02, 09:53
- question about methodology-Lorenzo's reply - JACK, 2012-02-02, 18:16
- the question remains... - ZihuaRob, 2012-02-02, 19:08
- the question remains... - ZihuaRob, 2012-02-08, 10:35
- the question remains... - ZihuaRob, 2012-02-02, 19:08
- question about methodology - ZihuaRob, 2012-02-02, 09:46

