A bit different?
I highly recommend Adolfo Gilly’s The Mexican Revolution: A People’s History (2nd edition). Trans.Patrick Camiller. (New York: The New Press, 2005). Written in a Mexican jail by an author who is now a perfessor.
You probably have not read a Marxist analysis of the revolution, have you?
You might be surprised by the book. It grapples with why the revolution failed including the flaws in Villa's approach ("They say my methods are unsound.Are my methods unsound, Cap'n Willard?" "I don't see any method."
and the failure of Zapata to articulate and implement his ideas. It also claims the Government eventually admitted it had Pancho Villa murdered which is a statement I have not read elsewhere. Fehrenbach’s Fire and Blood blames it on the spouses of Villa’s rape victims.
Reviewer wrote: The new English-language edition of Gilly’s book presents a
more plausible analysis (than the 1st edition) of the Mexican Revolution, one that would not be hindered by the rigidity of certain Marxist categories and concepts.
Complete thread:
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - Gringo Viejo, 2012-05-07, 18:03
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - ZihuaRob, 2012-05-07, 18:12
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - carl, 2012-05-07, 19:21
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - JeffMN, 2012-05-08, 11:08
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - Lee@98223, 2012-05-07, 22:54
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - carl, 2012-05-08, 11:41
- A bit different? - Oeste Hermoso, 2012-05-08, 13:51
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - RJ, 2012-05-08, 15:02
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - Phil In Toronto, 2012-05-08, 18:56
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - NoName, 2012-05-08, 19:11
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - Phil In Toronto, 2012-05-08, 18:56
- Best book on Mexico's history-- - ZihuaRob, 2012-05-07, 18:12

