Avatar

Zih and Be Seen

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 12:28 (3498 days ago)

What a difference this week from the last. There are still plenty of tourists here, but they aren't as raucous or as careless as the tourists last week. Much fewer buses and fewer cars though many tourists continue arriving by car as well as by plane. While the government reports their cifras alegres (albeit with starkly differing numbers between dependencias), the shop and restaurant owners know the score. Some restaurant owners have been criticized for adding 10% tip to their bills, but I think it is fair and correct to do so as long as it clearly states so on the bill. I have no problem with it since way too many folks simply don't leave a decent tip, meaning waiters go home with little pay for their day's work.

[image]

[image]

Zih and Be Seen

by Sun Seeker, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 12:33 (3498 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

Muy hermosa!

Zih and Be Seen

by JACK @, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 12:51 (3498 days ago) @ Sun Seeker

Although I don't agree with it, any service charges should be plainly visible on the MENU, not shown on the bill as a surprise at the end of the meal. That happened to me at La Ropa; not only they did add 11% to the bill, they didn't bother to show in the amount on the bill, it was simply added into the total. Never went back.

Avatar

Zih and Be Seen

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 13:33 (3498 days ago) @ JACK

Although I don't agree with it, any service charges should be plainly visible on the MENU, not shown on the bill as a surprise at the end of the meal. That happened to me at La Ropa; not only they did add 11% to the bill, they didn't bother to show in the amount on the bill, it was simply added into the total. Never went back.

How the hell are they supposed to put the 10% charges on the menu?

It's a practice usually reserved for Semana Santa and Navidad. As a former restaurant worker I find it NO BIG DEAL to ask if the tip was included if I am unable to tell from the bill, though it's usually obvious if it's been included.

Avatar

Zih and Be Seen

by frostbite @, Hamilton MT, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 13:53 (3498 days ago) @ ZihuaRob


How the hell are they supposed to put the 10% charges on the menu?

Easy enough: "A 10% gratuity will be added to the bill". I've seen that in the States, but generally only for larger groups. I don't like restaurants telling me how much to tip. I generally tip 20%, but if they add 10% that's all they get and I'll take my business elsewhere, in the future. On occasion, when paying with a credit card, I've been asked to leave cash by the waiter. Makes you wonder about their employer...

Avatar

Zih and Be Seen

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 14:49 (3498 days ago) @ frostbite


How the hell are they supposed to put the 10% charges on the menu?


Easy enough: "A 10% gratuity will be added to the bill". I've seen that in the States, but generally only for larger groups. I don't like restaurants telling me how much to tip. I generally tip 20%, but if they add 10% that's all they get and I'll take my business elsewhere, in the future. On occasion, when paying with a credit card, I've been asked to leave cash by the waiter. Makes you wonder about their employer...

Which part of "It's a practice usually reserved for Semana Santa and Navidad" didn't you understand? Even if they print it on the menu you already stated you wouldn't tip more, so I fail to see the difference.

You can sure tell who the elitists and who the wage workers are. So if they add it you penalize them even when you know that most people are lousy tippers and waiters struggle to survive. Aren't you just a sweetheart. Are you aware most waiters only get paid via the tips they make?

Zih and Be Seen

by Vermont123, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 18:26 (3498 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I don't like being told how much to tip either. Tips are reserved for good service. If you give poor service a tip to reward this does not make sense to me. However, that being said I have only once in my life left a zero tip for bad service. I typically tip 18 to 20% and do the same when I'm in Mexico. I don't know why people (tourists) who visit there think that they can get away with tipping poorly. It is so disrespectful in my mind.... but, then again, so are the employers who employ these people. Shame on them for the low salaries they pay their employees.

Avatar

HUGE MISUNDERSTANDING RE: RESTAURANTS & TIPS

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 20:12 (3497 days ago) @ Vermont123

I don't like being told how much to tip either. Tips are reserved for good service. If you give poor service a tip to reward this does not make sense to me. However, that being said I have only once in my life left a zero tip for bad service. I typically tip 18 to 20% and do the same when I'm in Mexico. I don't know why people (tourists) who visit there think that they can get away with tipping poorly. It is so disrespectful in my mind.... but, then again, so are the employers who employ these people. Shame on them for the low salaries they pay their employees.

There appear to be no current or former restaurant workers in this conversation, so get ready for an epiphany: RESTAURANTS DO NOT HAVE TO PAY MINIMUM WAGE! I worked way too many years in all kinds of restaurants in true elite class resort areas and the going wage was around a dollar an hour. Here in Mexico it is a lot less. THAT'S A FACT OF LIFE FOR RESTAURANT WORKERS.

NO ONE IS TELLING YOU HOW MUCH TO TIP OR THAT YOU MUST TIP AT ALL BY ADDING 10% TO THE BILL. You may have the tip removed from the bill by simply asking if you wish to leave no tip. It is not mandatory. It is added to help the wait staff and as a convenience for folks unaccustomed to tipping or for whom tipping is a cumbersome calculation.

Regardless of what the custom or law is where you come from, this ain't there. Here our waiters are unfortunately accustomed to too many tourists leaving no tip. It isn't the fault of the restaurants that wait staff live from tips, as especially Europeans like to allege. It is simply our way of operating restaurants. A different culture. There is nothing disrespectful about restaurants not paying waiters minimum wage or adding a 10% tip to a bill. We are fine with it. You don't have to like it or approve of it. I'm simply trying to make you aware of it so I don't have to read 50 more comments from folks indignant about standard practices in a local industry they don't work in.

For all of you current and former restaurant workers, this message is not for you.

HUGE MISUNDERSTANDING RE: RESTAURANTS & TIPS

by victorio, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 23:27 (3497 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
edited by victorio, Friday, April 21, 2017, 02:23

Hola
We just left Z after 6 months. Will be back in October. We always "tip" about 20% whether it is a bar or a restaurant. Haven't run across a place that has added a 10% tip to the tab. I would be saving money if they would.

YHUGE MISUNDERSTANDING RE: RESTAURANTS & TIPS

by ZihuaRx @, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 23:34 (3497 days ago) @ victorio

Yeah, or you would just add another 10%....not that big of a deal...

HUGE MISUNDERSTANDING RE: RESTAURANTS & TIPS

by OlsenMN, Friday, April 21, 2017, 11:27 (3497 days ago) @ ZihuaRob


Regardless of what the custom or law is where you come from, this ain't there. Here our waiters are unfortunately accustomed to too many tourists leaving no tip. It isn't the fault of the restaurants that wait staff live from tips, as especially Europeans like to allege. It is simply our way of operating restaurants. A different culture. There is nothing disrespectful about restaurants not paying waiters minimum wage or adding a 10% tip to a bill. We are fine with it.

This may not be THERE but here, those of us who live here are aware that Profeco makes this practice illegal.http://www.profeco.gob.mx/verificacion/quejas_denun.asp

Avatar

The Law

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Friday, April 21, 2017, 12:00 (3497 days ago) @ OlsenMN


Regardless of what the custom or law is where you come from, this ain't there. Here our waiters are unfortunately accustomed to too many tourists leaving no tip. It isn't the fault of the restaurants that wait staff live from tips, as especially Europeans like to allege. It is simply our way of operating restaurants. A different culture. There is nothing disrespectful about restaurants not paying waiters minimum wage or adding a 10% tip to a bill. We are fine with it.


This may not be THERE but here, those of us who live here are aware that Profeco makes this practice illegal.http://www.profeco.gob.mx/verificacion/quejas_denun.asp

You are mistaken. It is NOT illegal to add a 10% tip to the bill. I've read the law. As long as we all understand what the definition of a tip is then there's no problem. Anyone not wishing to pay the tip can have the bill adjusted to remove the added tip. No problem. No restaurant that adds a tip to the bill will insist that you must pay the tip.

Here's the relevant law everyone likes to cite. As long as the tip is marked as such on the bill or otherwise brought to the attention of the consumer there is no violation of the law.

LEY FEDERAL DE PROTECCIÓN AL CONSUMIDOR

ARTÍCULO 10.- Queda prohibido a cualquier proveedor de bienes o servicios llevar a cabo acciones que atenten contra la libertad o seguridad o integridad personales de los consumidores bajo pretexto de registro o averiguación. En el caso de que alguien sea sorprendido en la comisión flagrante de un delito, los proveedores, sus agentes o empleados se limitarán, bajo su responsabilidad, a poner sin demora al presunto infractor a disposición de la autoridad competente. La infracción de esta disposición se sancionará de acuerdo con lo previsto en esta ley, independientemente de la reparación del daño moral y la indemnización por los daños y perjuicios ocasionados en caso de no comprobarse el delito imputado.

Los proveedores no podrán aplicar métodos o prácticas comerciales coercitivas y desleales, ni cláusulas o condiciones abusivas o impuestas en el abastecimiento de productos o servicios. Asimismo, tampoco podrán prestar servicios adicionales a los originalmente contratados que no hubieren sido solicitados o aceptados expresamente, por escrito o por vía electrónica, por el consumidor.

http://www.profeco.gob.mx/juridico/pdf/LFPC_actuali_16ene2013.pdf

Zih and Be Seen

by Canada1, Thursday, April 20, 2017, 23:00 (3497 days ago) @ ZihuaRob


How the hell are they supposed to put the 10% charges on the menu?


Easy enough: "A 10% gratuity will be added to the bill". I've seen that in the States, but generally only for larger groups. I don't like restaurants telling me how much to tip. I generally tip 20%, but if they add 10% that's all they get and I'll take my business elsewhere, in the future. On occasion, when paying with a credit card, I've been asked to leave cash by the waiter. Makes you wonder about their employer...


Which part of "It's a practice usually reserved for Semana Santa and Navidad" didn't you understand? Even if they print it on the menu you already stated you wouldn't tip more, so I fail to see the difference.

You can sure tell who the elitists and who the wage workers are. So if they add it you penalize them even when you know that most people are lousy tippers and waiters struggle to survive. Aren't you just a sweetheart. Are you aware most waiters only get paid via the tips they make?

Rob, some don't even get a fare share of tips as the owner pays at the end of the night, they get their min wage for the day, anything left over the owner takes.

Avatar

Zih and Be Seen

by Craig AKA the cruise ship guy @, Friday, April 21, 2017, 09:02 (3497 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I totally agree with Rob. There are too many people that don't tip and I don't want to feel like I need to make up for them. It's on the bill and obvious so it's not like they are trying to scam you. It's standard procedure in Panama and Costa Rica so you shouldn't go there if it bothers you. Some people/cultures don't get tipping but that's not going to feed the waiters family. I really feel bad for the maids who don't get tipped like they should. Going to San Francisco for the weekend and many restaurants have added a surcharge for the price of doing business in San Francisco, you gotta love that one.

Zih and Be Seen

by rdcosta @, Monday, April 24, 2017, 09:55 (3494 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I definitely don't have a problem with a tip,in fact I tell most people I eat with, 15 percent, what I have a problem with is it being put on the bill automatically. Not often but once in a while the service, or the meal,is not up to standard and I like to be able to let them know, by the amount of the tip