Very disappointing

by tj, Monday, October 10, 2011, 15:22 (5520 days ago)

After exchanging e-mails with friends we've made in Ixtapa through the years, I've just learned that a group of 22 people made up of Minnesota and Wisconsin couples, will not be returning after 13 consecutive years. Most all meet while staying at the Krystal the first year or two and then eventually made the Dorado Pacifico their annual 2 week home. Three weeks ago while putting together their 2012 trip they became aware of the new ownership and the "All Reclusive" requirement. Due to some bad experience at the Krystal and with no other comparable hotel offering a European plan, they have decided to go to PV. The pool bar at the Dorado and convenient location across from the commercial area was a big factor. Sad because this was a reunion every year and as my wife said, we may never see some of those people again.

Very disappointing

by LadyM in Zihua, Monday, October 10, 2011, 18:24 (5520 days ago) @ tj

The changes in the AI's in Ixtapa have encouraged national folks and discouraged foreigners. That is too bad. Possibly they have not investigated into the rates enough or possibly they thought it was time for a change. Either way, there is a market for both kinds of hotels and lodging but unfortunately Ixtapa seems to be going for just one. I hope that brings more people to Zihua, but if you want open ocean that won't be the same. Remember to let us know how they like PV.

Very disappointing.... other options?...many !!

by LaurieMac, B.C. Canada, Monday, October 10, 2011, 19:16 (5520 days ago) @ tj

After exchanging e-mails with friends we've made in Ixtapa through the years, I've just learned that a group of 22 people made up of Minnesota and Wisconsin couples, will not be returning after 13 consecutive years. Most all meet while staying at the Krystal the first year or two and then eventually made the Dorado Pacifico their annual 2 week home. Three weeks ago while putting together their 2012 trip they became aware of the new ownership and the "All Reclusive" requirement. Due to some bad experience at the Krystal and with no other comparable hotel offering a European plan, they have decided to go to PV. The pool bar at the Dorado and convenient location across from the commercial area was a big factor. Sad because this was a reunion every year and as my wife said, we may never see some of those people again.

Folks should always look outside of booking a hotel, for a large group there are villas with 6-12 rooms, staff to cook and clean, views of the bays or directly on the beach. There are many newer condo developments that the owners or property managers will negotiate on the advertised rates as well with all the amenities --- everything from bbq's to blenders as well as poolside food service, security with access to cabs and buses at their doorstep. We have been to PV [as well] but it will never compare to Zihua and Ixtapa. It is sad.

Avatar

High rises and A/I's

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, October 10, 2011, 20:41 (5520 days ago) @ LaurieMac

Folks should always look outside of booking a hotel, for a large group there are villas with 6-12 rooms, staff to cook and clean, views of the bays or directly on the beach. There are many newer condo developments that the owners or property managers will negotiate on the advertised rates as well with all the amenities --- everything from bbq's to blenders as well as poolside food service, security with access to cabs and buses at their doorstep. We have been to PV [as well] but it will never compare to Zihua and Ixtapa. It is sad.

Right on. Personally, I think folks seeking high-rise hotel accommodations should stick to the Gulf Coast of Florida. :stirpot:

And I just can't feel bad to see the Ixtapa all-inclusives losing any business. The locals tourist industry folks pretty much despise them as do I. They have proven to be quite bad for our local economy.

My thoughts on PV vs Z/X

by TheDon, Monday, October 10, 2011, 20:58 (5520 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I'm a former Z-junkie who converted to PV. I too had a bad experience(s) in the Zee area but still enjoyed Ixtapa. That said I still like Zee and want to go back, there is no place comparable to it in all of Mexico except maybe Huatulco.

I don't think the beaches of PV compare to Zee at all. I don't like Bucerias, I think it is somewhat seedy and worn down. Nuevo Vallarta has a nicer beach, one comparable to Playa Del Mar but not as nice as Playa La Ropa.

However, the best beach in the PV area is 1 hour north - Rincon De Guayabitos has a beach as nice as La Ropa - soft sand, very swimmable, calm wake and tons of hotels that are very cheap (think 60-70 bucks for a beachfront view). RDG is a bit of a secret, mostly Mexican families vacation there. It doesn't have much in the way of restaurants or surrounding ambiance like Zee does but it offers great value, safety and authentic Mexican culture. Also I find it to be really good for children.

My thoughts on PV vs Z/X

by El Tacaño, Monday, October 10, 2011, 21:19 (5520 days ago) @ TheDon

I went to PV for 12 years straight & have returned several times since. There is much to like & enjoy.
Little gems like Los Cuatro Vientos, Posada Roger, some wonderful out of the way cafés & real Mexican neighborhoods but a 10 minute bus ride from the Malacon.
The biggest downer IMO is The Constant (And I mean constant) hassle of the parade of beach Vendors. One must keep a book in one's face looking neither right or left to not be bothered. Even this does not always work.
The only beach this is not true in PV proper that I found is the little postage stamp one below the Lindo-Mar.
I'll take Zihua anytime!

Avatar

My thoughts on PV vs Z/X

by DEBMN @, rosemount mn, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 07:36 (5519 days ago) @ El Tacaño

We went to PV for the first time last year just because I wanted to try something different. We loved the fact that there is so much to do there; we like to explore our surroundings. What we didn't like, and why we won't go back for quite some time if at all, is the never ending and constant pestering by vendors. It is horrible! And the beaches do not compare to Z at all. We love the Catalina in Z, and have never even considered doing an AI in any place we've visited. Even when we travel with friends and they stay at AI's, we stay someplace else and just meet them for an occasional dinner or drink. There are so many great places to eat and so many nice people to meet, why on earth would you want to stay in your compound!

High rises and A/I's

by LadyM in Zihua, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 01:01 (5520 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

The bad thing I see about Ixtapa hotels loosing the business is whatever business from foreigners that floats over to Zihua. If they are not in Ixtapa at all Zihua gets nothing. Even the tips etc. the locals get there get put into the Zihua market no matter how slight. Other than those things, I agree that AI's are not good for the area.

Avatar

High rises and A/I's

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 08:47 (5519 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Ixtapa's tourism the past few weekends has generated nothing for anyone in Zihuatanejo. They sleep, eat, shop and play at the all-inclusive hotels, who of course do their banking elsewhere.

If the government won't "induce" them to offer a non-A/I alternative, then as far as I'm concerned they can fail and all their from-out-of-town staff can go back to where they came from. The waiters, maids and floor sweepers (the only locals they hire) should be able to find employment as the locally owned businesses pick up the slack.

High rises and A/I's

by LadyM in Zihua, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 13:50 (5519 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

I guess I should have been more specific and said NON-Mexican tourists. All the people I know that stay in AI come to Zihua, shop, eat and drink and partake of the area. I do agree on the week-enders. Do you think those week-enders would even come to Zihua if Ixtapa were not here? Acapulco maybe?

Avatar

High rises and A/I's

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 14:38 (5519 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Do you think those week-enders would even come to Zihua if Ixtapa were not here? Acapulco maybe?

I recall when Zihuatanejo did just fine without Ixtapa. And the locals prospered more directly from tourism, too.

High rises and A/I's

by El Tacaño, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 09:45 (5519 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

I know a woman in San Francisco who went with her family to a AI in Ixtapa who never came to Zihua. Blew my mind.

High rises and A/I's

by islandgirl @, Cowichan Valley, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 13:35 (5519 days ago) @ El Tacaño

There was a fellow on here about 9 months ago, asking for advice on Z. He'd been going every year for 9 years to Ixtapa, and this was to be his first foray into Zihua. Wish he would have done a trip report to tell us about his Zihua adventures.

Avatar

High rises and A/I's

by Zmon01 @, Tuesday, October 11, 2011, 15:09 (5519 days ago) @ islandgirl

Friends of ours (he being the County Sheriff) stayed in I for a week. About mid week they made plans to go to Z for dinner. Once they got downtown Z, told the cabbie to take them back to I. Never got out of the cab and haven't been to I since.:beatwall: