Avatar

Which Golf Course?

by JeffMN ⌂ @, Minneapolis MN USA, Monday, December 19, 2011, 16:30 (5450 days ago)

Not a golfer myself, but I want to gift a round of golf to my son-in-law, who'll be down to see us in Feb.

Much of what I find in the archives here is pretty old. So, what's the current dope on the two courses?

I'm leaning toward Marina, since it seems not to have as many recent complaints about untimely price increases. Help!

One Man's Wonder

--
http://www.OneMansWonder.com

Which Golf Course?

by Jackson88 @, Monday, December 19, 2011, 18:30 (5450 days ago) @ JeffMN

Jeff
I usually play them both when we are in Ixtapa. I would not consider either of them a good value. Why do I golf in Ixtapa then? Just because I can not play at home in February. I would lean more toward the Marina course just because it has been cheaper the last couple of years. Also, check with your hotel to see if they have a discount program in place for either course. Hope this helps.

Which Golf Course?

by JBinCT, Monday, December 19, 2011, 20:20 (5450 days ago) @ JeffMN
edited by JBinCT, Monday, December 19, 2011, 20:29

Jeff, I have played both quite a few times but not in the last couple years. As Jackson says, neither is a good value and both fall short of golf experiences available in other parts of Mexico, but you play golf on the courses you have, not the courses you wish you had, or something like that. If I had to make your choice I would gift the Robert Trent Jones Jr. course, Palma Real, for the simple reason that the crocodiles and the beach front/view holes on the back 9 make it a more memorable round. The Marina course is (was) in better shape and if the quality of golf is your sole criteria pick Marina. But if you want to share an only-in-Mexico experience, hire a caddy, buy plenty of beer, bring your camera and play Palma Real.

Avatar

Which Golf Course?

by Dave&Betty @, Los Altos, CA, Monday, December 19, 2011, 20:32 (5450 days ago) @ JeffMN

We have played both several times. If I had to pick one to play again it would be the Marina course, but not at all by a long shot. It just seemed more fun, but then if you have a bad day on a course what are ya gonna blame, the course, your clubs, worn out cleats? Certainly not your golf ability ;-)

--
Today is non-returnable, make the most of it

Which Golf Course?

by gailrick, Thursday, December 22, 2011, 14:37 (5447 days ago) @ JeffMN

The marina course is more challenging, in better shape and has water on 14 holes. Bring plenty of balls. I love the course.