confused about protestors
by seatown, Monday, December 19, 2011, 18:02 (5450 days ago)
I can't seem to find a coherent statement about what happened with the student teacher protestors in Chilpanchigo - anyone have a good link? Also, was there as sister protest in Zihua, or was that over something different? Thanks for the info.
confused about protestors
by TerryK, Monday, December 19, 2011, 19:49 (5450 days ago) @ seatown
Here you go.....and yes there was a demonstration at the Artisan Market in Zihuatanejo
confused about protestors
by seatown, Monday, December 19, 2011, 21:26 (5450 days ago) @ TerryK
thanks for the link Terry - it sad to see what force was used with the students - and people think the Occupy Wall-Streeters are being roughed - nothing like this...
Was the Zihua protest about the same thing or a separate issue?
little sympathy deserved
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Wednesday, December 21, 2011, 12:19 (5448 days ago) @ TerryK
I don't know about any demonstration at the artisans' market, but there was a small demonstration at the Plaza Libertad de Expresión.
While the students' deaths are lamentable, it is also lamentable that these so-called students are allowed to block traffic wherever they please and extort money from drivers and steal gasoline from vehicles, sometimes stealing buses and other vehicles, too. It is also lamentable that the students apparently set fire to a gas station after stealing gasoline to make molotov cocktails, and the ensuing explosion severely injured the gas station attendant (who later died from the injuries) while closing valves that avoided an even larger explosion.
These so-called students went looking for trouble and found it. Their actions for many years have been more akin to delinquent gangs than students seeking to become teachers, and the ones who have gone on to become teachers must be at least partially responsible for the atrociously low level of education provided in our state's schools. I feel sorry for children who are students of these types of graduates.
By the way, the demonstration wasn't so much about the poor conditions of their school since most schools in the state are in deplorable conditions, often much worse than theirs, as much as it was about being guaranteed jobs and being excluded from having to take teacher competency exams like other teachers are supposed to take.
The sympathy they are getting is mostly for political purposes, as exemplified by the protests by the PRD and PT parties. Folks from Guerrero familiar with the history of these protestors have little sympathy for them but are nonetheless indignant with the response of the state government under the now ex-state attorney who first tried to throw a scapegoat in front of the press and then tried to blame the federal officials (standard operating procedure), ignoring the many videos which clearly show a handful of state ministerial police in plain clothes aiming and firing their weapons at students in addition to other state police kicking students (even if they might have deserved it).
little sympathy deserved
by seatown, Wednesday, December 21, 2011, 18:39 (5448 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Thanks Rob - this is frankly more along the lines of what I was looking for in regards to what's going on. All I could find were quick articles about students being shot embedded in articles about corrupt police, thus I was hoping someone with more insight/local knowledge could enlighten me. Truly no winners and the biggest losers continuing to be the local people.
confused about protestors
by Bill
, Chicago, Illinois, Monday, December 19, 2011, 21:37 (5450 days ago) @ seatown
None of us were there so we don't know exactly what happened. What we know is what we read in published reports. Reports which may or not be accurate.
Having said that, if reports are accurate, there were hundreds of people blocking a busy federal highway and who first attacked the police. My guess is that the police were somewhat restrained in their response and it's surprising more of the violent demonstraters weren't injured or killed as a result of their actions.
This is my reaction after seeing many such demonstrations and reading a lot about others.
Many people are disenfranchised in Mexico due to an unresponsive and/or corrupt government. They feel the only to get attention is to turn to violent demonstrations. There are no winners in such confrontations.
confused about protestors
by seatown, Wednesday, December 21, 2011, 18:48 (5448 days ago) @ Bill
thanks for a bit more info - I must be a lame googler as I only found 2 articles (that were slanted towards the protests)- of course part of the problem may be that I don't speak Spanish so that limits my hits. Anyhow, just trying to find out what's really going on rather than what the US news gets.

