Driving in Mexico Part 2

by HolyMole, Wednesday, May 16, 2012, 16:44 (5301 days ago)

I’ve been itching to tell this story for the past 6 months because it’s worth telling, even if the protagonists have been somewhat reluctant. I apologize if my memory has jumbled some of the details, but the gist is this:

Back in mid-November/11, “Bill” and “Suzanne” were driving through Acapulco in their Canadian-plated vehicle, when they were pulled over by police, allegedly for speeding. (I don’t recall which police they were - transit, municipal, state or federal highway). It quickly became evident it was nothing more than a shakedown: a cash-grab by corrupt cops. Although he now feels he should not have done so, Bill surrendered his driver’s license to the male police officer, while the officer’s female partner stood nearby re-directing on-coming traffic, apparently as much in an effort to discourage any witnesses as for traffic safety. The officer showed Bill a printed chart listing various fines for speeding infractions - 6000 pesos in Bill’s case - which could be reduced to 3000 pesos if paid in cash, on-the-spot, to the officer.

Bill and Suzanne replied they didn’t have that much cash with them. Finally, they “settled” for the entire contents of Bill’s wallet, 1400 pesos. The officer returned Bill’s driver’s license, and the travellers were on their way.

End of story? Just a $110 introduction to Mexican police corruption? No, not for Bill and Suzanne, who, between them, carefully reconstructed exactly what had happened: date, time of day, precise location, weather conditions, physical description of the two police officers, details of the shakedown, etc.

Bill then got busy on his computer, drafting an e-mail that described in full and complete detail what had transpired. He expressed his disappointment that any motorist, whether Mexican national or foreign tourist, should have to put up with such blatant criminal activity from the very people entrusted to protect the public, and that this kind of police behavior could only discourage tourism. In tone, Bill’s e-mail was more an expression of disappointment, rather than an angry complaint.

Bill then went on the Internet and found the e-mail addresses for literally dozens of individuals who he thought should be interested in his story. This list of contacts included those responsible for tourism for the city of Acapulco and for the state of Guerrero, the municipal president/mayor of Acapulco, the Acapulco chief of police, the governor of Guerrero, President Calderon, as well as the Mexican Federal Minister of Tourism, their counterparts in various departments of the Canadian government, the Canadian High Commission in Mexico City, the Canadian consul in Acapulco, etc.

The apologies started rolling in. Based on the detailed information Bill had provided, an investigation had begun into the allegations made against the two police officers. Then, miraculously, and although Bill had never requested nor expected it, through the combined efforts of the Mexican federal, state and municipal governments, and officials in the Canadian government, Bill’s Canadian bank account was credited with the dollar equivalent of the 1400 pesos stolen from him.

Avatar

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by Lani @, Wednesday, May 16, 2012, 17:29 (5301 days ago) @ HolyMole

Wow, that's quite a story. Sorry to hear about the corruption. Glad it had a rather happy ending (if that is possible).

I went through a pick-pocket type theft a number of years ago and a horrendous process of getting my tourist card re-issued over a two-day period.

Avatar

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by NoName @, Vancouver Island, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 10:31 (5300 days ago) @ Lani

You know, we should all follow up on these types of crimes and report them ... we should generate a list of addresses we could have on hand ... I wonder which of the individual recipients of their report initiated the manner in which they dealt with the complaint. Tourism is important, as are the moral obligations we have to each other.

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by HolyMole, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 12:48 (5300 days ago) @ NoName

You know, we should all follow up on these types of crimes and report them ... we should generate a list of addresses we could have on hand ... I wonder which of the individual recipients of their report initiated the manner in which they dealt with the complaint. Tourism is important, as are the moral obligations we have to each other.

After driving from B.C. to Zihua five years in a row, we decided to fly last winter precisely because we began hearing one too many stories of travellers being shaken-down by crooked Mexican cops.
(We found flying to be a much less pleasant experience than we had recalled, so we're in a bit of a quandary now, but that's another issue).
I thought of requesting a few business cards from the Canadian consulates in Mazatlan and in Acapulco - or, probably much more effective, a business card from the US Consul in Ixtapa. Maybe, if stopped for a shakedown, a cop would be a tad hesitant if presented with one of the cards and told that you intended to call the consulate immediately. On the other hand, that kind of overt threat might get one trussed-up like a hog and dumped in a ditch.
A few years ago, it seemed that shakedowns were nothing but a relatively minor irritant: 200 pesos and the crooked cop was happy. No longer. Now it's more likely to be a demand for $300 or $600 US. And if you don't have the cash, they'll accompany you to an ATM. Or they'll offer you the alternative of going to the police station, but you must leave your vehicle where it is, the clear implication being that it won't be there when you get back.

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by Average Joe, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 15:16 (5300 days ago) @ HolyMole

Wonderful story about the ‘credit’ to your bank account!! DEFINITELY a rare and rather surprising outcome. Karma??? (;-D

But gosh.... I sincerely believe that “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure”! And although I would be (sorta) inclined to agree with your general assessment about potential attempts at “shakedowns” when driving through México, I will also laudably insist that such incidents are really a comparatively infrequent occurrence..... at least amid our very regular travels throughout the entire republic.

While having ALL of your ‘papers in order’; knowing Mexican law; respecting Mexican law, and speaking Spanish certainly has its benefits (as does ‘dressing local’ versus like a ‘tourist’ when driving a foreign-plated vehicle), it is my experience that firmly standing your ground.... confidently and COURTEOUSLY.... in such infrequent occasions definitely results in near-immediately dissipating such mordida attempts.

In fact, I have found that those “shakedown” attempters are ALWAYS (duly) startled by someone absolutely UNintimidated by such ploys (usually ONLY tried by low-paid city cops in distinctly tourist destinations, and occasionally among poor soldiers at hwy military stops), as their predicted response goes sumthun like, “Who the hell is THIS guy arguing with me, when I’M the one with the frickin M16.....”!! UNarguably, a good question!

Seriously though, a March drive from OAX to California and back, let alone a recent 10-day trip from OAX throughout the Sierra Nahua in interior Guerrero to Zihua, and even last week up through remote highland Michoacán to Jalisco and on to Guanajuato over seven days, had literally ZERO ‘incidents’ of The Mordida Kind, even as passing thru numerous road check-stops along the various routes.

Our only experience in such “shakedown” attempts over the past FIVE+ years of extensive México travel was last December also in “tourist” Acapulco, where two city cops tried to hassle me for having my rearview mirror ‘view’ blocked by the car being TOTALLY Packed with (yet another round of) pottery and artesanía purchases. While I KNOW that that is not against the law in MX (as I have two ‘legally functioning’ side mirrors), “it” immediately evaporated when I finally insisted that we simply drive down to the station and confirm with El Jefe that my vehicle was in infraction.... End of discussion, and off we drove without ANY further incident, let alone ‘payment’!!

An exact same scenario.... and result.... transpired a year ago with us while in DF, when two city motorcycle cops tried to hassle me for what they claimed as my car windows being “tinted too dark”.

As most such incidents historically occur in large degree around border areas (again “tourist” areas with foreign-plated vehicles), my advice is to simply cross the border early a.m.; get well beyond the border before most “attempters” are even AWAKE (!); be attentive to and obey traffic signs/laws everywhere; always Stand Your Ground (in México or elsewhere!), and simply drive in peace and confidence! And staying attune to the nightly news in your varying hotel areas is of equal import.

So in general IMHO, fagetaboutit, and disfruta TODO..... en paz y seguridad, with an always-attentive sense of your surroundings (and a BIG courteous smile..... UNintimidated!).

[image]

Ooooops, gotz ta startz-a-packin for our continuing the next 7-day+ road trip down to DF, highland Metepec, up to Taxco, and back to Z..... with yet again the “rearview mirror ‘view’ TOTALLY blocked”! = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atC-QsMJGPE

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by HolyMole, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 16:56 (5300 days ago) @ Average Joe

Wonderful story about the ‘credit’ to your bank account!! DEFINITELY a rare and rather surprising outcome. Karma??? (;-D

I'm just the messenger. It happened to acquaintances of ours.

But gosh....I will also laudably insist that such incidents are really a comparatively infrequent occurrence..... at least amid our very regular travels throughout the entire republic.

We've also driven thousands of km in Mexico over the past 6 years, and have yet to experience a clear shakedown attempt. But I wasn't kidding about hearing credible stories from friends and acquaintances suggesting not only an increase in the frequency of these events, but in the boldness and greediness of the cops.
And perhaps I'm a tad too sensitive, but it would only take one expensive shakedown to ruin a vacation for me.

While having ALL of your ‘papers in order’; knowing Mexican law; respecting Mexican law, and speaking Spanish certainly has its benefits (as does ‘dressing local’ versus like a ‘tourist’ when driving a foreign-plated vehicle), it is my experience that firmly standing your ground.... confidently and COURTEOUSLY.... in such infrequent occasions definitely results in near-immediately dissipating such mordida attempts.

The only time we were stopped for no apparent reason, near Alamos, we decided, as the cop strode to our vehicle, that we would feign a total ignorance of Spanish. It apparently worked, because he gave up quickly and walked away. And he never did offer any hints that he wanted money, so we're at a loss as to why he pulled us over.
We were legitimately pulled over in San Luis Potosi for going through a red light. The officer actually started writing the ticket, but gave up when he came to the block asking for my "Estado", after I explained that Canada has "provinces", not "states". Maybe he just liked Canadians, eh?

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by Average Joe, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 19:00 (5300 days ago) @ HolyMole

And perhaps I'm a tad too sensitive, but it would only take one expensive shakedown to ruin a vacation for me <

Chale, CHALE and certainly 100% agreed, mate.... with the key word being “expensive”.

ISR, our regular habit is to always travel with a small framed foto of both our parents (Cely’s folks in ropa tipica Mixteca and mine in Classic Aussie gear!) that we keep on the front console in FULL view.... indelibly ‘punctuated’ with a small reverent Virgin of Guadalupe in the lower corner of the frame. (;-D

INSIDE the foto frame is stashed ALL of our cash, with only a 100mxp “redie” in each of our wallets. Soooo, if push EVER ‘comes to shove’ (as it did in Oaxaca Capital a couple of years back in a little “my fault” rear-end fender kiss), then we can demonstrably show that all we have in our possession in ANY circumstance is a mere “greenie” 200mxp total!

Thus again, if further hassled, then we simply insist that we all drive to The Station to talk to El Jefe, after which we would have to find a Banamex ATM in order to ‘pay the fine’..... Which again, either evaporates the issue entirely on-the-spot, or, we “escape” for a mere $16 USD MAX!! And I ONLY pay when I am clearly in the wrong, vs. the unjustified, intimidated “shakedown” attempt.

And, in just such cases where I AM in the wrong, I actually consider such on-street payment as NOT some illicit Mordida, but in fact as a very welcome Public Service! And THAT sentiment goes double in light of the municipal cops in justifiably appreciating that these low-paid city police are in a majority of cases earning often less than an equivalent of USD $200 per month..... to feed their families!

SÍ, el gusto es mio por eso, cabrón, as it sure beats having to hang around extra days (ala stateside), go to court and wait IN LINE for hours, and inevitably pay to the court the SAME general amount as you do ‘on-the-street’..... for that MUCH appreciated ‘pay-n-go’ basis!! AKA: just my .02

[image]

And OH..... I just met a cordial Mexican fella here at our hotel in SMA this morning (The Quinto Loreto) who nationally markets the brand ‘BRU-XO’ of Oaxacan mezcal, and who generously ‘gifted’ me two LITERS of this nice “hoven”. While I am sipping it now, it is a ‘brand’ well worth checking-out, and comes from the central highland area of San Dionisio = www.bruxomezcal.com = While a bit pricey compared to our 20+ year finca supplier in Matatlán, OAX.... well.... when ya gotz to havez it (etc., etc., etc.), and apparently marketed stateside now! (;-D

Provecho..... y VIVA México siempre!

Driving in Mexico Part 2

by Average Joe, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 15:22 (5300 days ago) @ NoName

Nice 'personal photo'..... (one of my favs!).

This Has Me A Little Worried

by wanderer, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 16:24 (5300 days ago) @ HolyMole

How in the world did they gain access to his bank account...?

This Has Me A Little Worried

by HolyMole, Thursday, May 17, 2012, 17:12 (5300 days ago) @ wanderer

How in the world did they gain access to his bank account...?

Obviously, once whichever party it was had ultimately agreed to
work out a refund, "Bill" presumably provided his banking information. The point is that his diligence had a positive outcome, not the mechanics of how that was finally achieved.