Aftermath of Iguala
by JeffMN
, Minneapolis MN USA, Monday, November 10, 2014, 12:48 (4392 days ago)
Here's a good article on the massacre in Iguala and its aftermath. How many such horrors will it take to start turning the tables on systemic corruption in Mexico? NYT ARTICLE
Aftermath of Iguala
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, November 10, 2014, 13:40 (4391 days ago) @ JeffMN
Here's a good article on the massacre in Iguala and its aftermath. How many such horrors will it take to start turning the tables on systemic corruption in Mexico? NYT ARTICLE
I respect Enrique Krauze, but he is still an outsider to Guerrero, though he comes damn close to getting it.
Corruption requires at least two parties. One look at the invaded hillsides of Zihuatanejo reminds me that as everywhere, you get the government you deserve. If people are going to behave like criminals then they shouldn't be the least surprised that their governments are made up of criminals.
Folks want to blame only the goverment for their own shortcomings. The single mom with ten children. The unemployed 5th grade drop out. The public official on the take. Hundreds of years of paternalistic religion and government have taken their toll, and no one is responsible anymore for their own situation. It's always the fault of "the authorities" and "the rich".
But as an existentialist I believe there is another dimension of responsibility that must be explored for both understanding what the problems are as well as for finding solutions. It's why my wife and I are very careful about to whom and where we offer our help and donations from my readers. It's why we often find ourselves at odds with some of the charitable organizations operating locally.
I sense a sea change in the air of Mexico, but it may all be lost because of the hot-headed protestors confusing issues and directing their anger at the wrong targets. Especially the folks destroying public property and calling for the President of the Republic to resign when not only did he have nothing to do with the tragedy but he's our best chance of hope, and here in Guerrero it's been the federal government who got the compromised and inept government of Aguirre out of the way. In the very manner in which the Procurador de Justicia de la República revealed the results and manner of their investigations, it was apparent things are changing. For example, instead of parading all the suspected guilty parties in front of cameras as has been the norm for the past decade or so, they appear to be taking more care so as not to screw up the case as was done with the French woman involved with a gang of kidnappers. They also did not reveal the names of suspects not yet apprehended as has been habitual in the past, thus not giving them warning and allowing them to escape. A good move. Let's hope these trends continue and that we see real justice done and a real attempt to clean up public administration in Mexico from top to bottom.
Aftermath of Iguala
by JeffMN
, Minneapolis MN USA, Monday, November 10, 2014, 15:55 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
It's good to hear your take on this, Rob, and respect your and Lupita's efforts to put your money where your mouths are.
I'm glad you think a sweeping change is possible, but as you said, this is a centuries-old pattern and cultural mindset. I'm afraid real change will require at least a few fearless, charismatic leaders...and probably the loss of many more lives. The perps won't give in without a fight.
Aftermath of Iguala
by katherine
, Monday, November 10, 2014, 17:17 (4391 days ago) @ JeffMN
I deplore the acts of violence, and also understand the extreme frustration that has sparked them. There has been impunity for violence for far too long. Hard to see how this situation can be resolved peacefully.
Broken societies and policies
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, November 10, 2014, 17:52 (4391 days ago) @ katherine
I deplore the acts of violence, and also understand the extreme frustration that has sparked them. There has been impunity for violence for far too long. Hard to see how this situation can be resolved peacefully.
According to the new governor of Guerrero, at least in our state it will have to be resolved peacefully because he refuses to use violence against violent protestors. I may not completely agree with him on this, but he is now our governor and I respect his point of view. He prefers to deal with the root causes. Now there's a novel idea!
It must not be overlooked that this problem has much to do with the failed policy that I'll just call Prohibition 2.0. And it is much exacerbated by the ease with which organized criminals are able to acquire firearms in the USA and bring them into Mexico. Yet instead of anything resembling co-responsibility on the part of our northern neighbors whose consumers fuel the multi-billion dollar a year black market that enables much of the organized criminals and the officials they corrupt, I see the tired old xenophobia and "exceptionalism". Instead of learning and applying the lessons of Prohibition (and Colorado, Washington and Oregon), our northern neighbor apparently prefers to build a Wall Of Shame and waste billions of dollars militarizing its police forces while at the same time calling for mass deportations of the victims of yet another broken policy: immigration.
Broken societies and policies
by katherine
, Monday, November 10, 2014, 18:07 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Unfortunately, dealing with the root causes seems like the hard part!! And mostly not in the Governor's control.
Broken societies and policies
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Monday, November 10, 2014, 18:57 (4391 days ago) @ katherine
I believe he means attending to the causes of poverty by improving education, improving access to health care, improving infrastructure, paying more attention to our agricultural sector, and trying to see how to better benefit Guerrero's residents from our mineral wealth and natural resources. Much of Guerrero is among the poorest regions on the planet, neglected year after year by corrupt and inept state officials beholden to caciques and political interests. Time for a change, no?
Broken societies and policies
by katherine
, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 07:01 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Yes, of course it is time for a change.
Seenyore Forum Maven...
by mexicowanderer, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 11:46 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
I must have written thirty letters to various USA agencies and legislators asking for an introduction of a bill that would prohibit the exportation or give assistance to the cause of exportation of firearms to Mexico without a federal license. Federal prison, 10-years without possibility of parole. The posting of giant freeway signs just before entering Mexico that read ILLEGAL TO BRING UNDECLARED FIREARMS INTO MEXICO. FELONY
I have not seen a single acknowledgement of my efforts. 90% of my letters were to Democratic leaders and legislators.
They just do not care. Racist bastards.
Aftermath of Iguala
by katherine
, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 07:03 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Rob, I totally get where you are coming from. But -- with your attitude, what happens to those 10 children born to the single mother? Don't they deserve to get a decent education, which might give them a chance to escape the life they were born into? It seems to me that education, along with good nutrition, is essential to the kind of change we are all seeking.
Aftermath of Iguala
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 08:35 (4391 days ago) @ katherine
Rob, I totally get where you are coming from. But -- with your attitude, what happens to those 10 children born to the single mother? Don't they deserve to get a decent education, which might give them a chance to escape the life they were born into? It seems to me that education, along with good nutrition, is essential to the kind of change we are all seeking.
I appreciate your wanting to take this on a tangent that has nothing to do with the subject.
First thing that happens before mom gets any public assistance is that mom gets her tubes tied. Society at large should not be made to keep paying the consequences for irresponsible parenthood generation after generation. The children go to public school like any other children. Relevant to Zihuatanejo, they don't need to steal public land or have a special school built for their neighborhood of land invaders with the help of foreigners.
But you miss the point. The cycle of poverty must be stopped at its source, and the source of the single mom with 10 children who wants public assistance whether in the USA or Mexico is that there must be a price for her to pay for being so irresponsible, because her children are doomed to pay a heavy price thanks to her lack of personal responsibility. Same with the 5th grade dropout standing around with his or her hand out waiting for public assistance. Public assistance should include making sure that dropout finishes a high-school education and at least 2 years of trade school (unless of course he or she shows an aptitude for a higher level of education). Remedies should be based on specific circumstances. Helping Mexico's rural poor is a different problem than helping Chicago's inner-city poor.
As a resident of Alaska what do you propose to help the poor there? The children of alcoholics or meth-heads? The homeless who borrowed too much and lost everything during the Bush economic bust? The unskilled unemployed and poorly educated with no prospect for employment? The former smokers now suffering health issues who can't find work they can do to support themselves? The Palin family after the GOP and TeaHats stops supporting them? 
Tangent?
by katherine
, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 09:23 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Rob -- you were the one who mentioned the single mother with 10 children. I was merely responding to your comment. None of these problems have simple solutions, whether in Mexico or Alaska. My point was that education can help people escape the circumstances of their birth. And as far as condemnation of the protestors, of course I deplore violence. But what about drug cartel violence? What about all of extortion, kidnappings, and murders? Where is the official outrage over the disappeared, not just the 43 students but the thousands or even tens of thousands? As far as I am concerned, official silence equals complicity. It is no wonder that people are fed up.
Desviación
by ZihuaRob
, Zihuatanejo, México, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 10:57 (4391 days ago) @ katherine
Rob -- you were the one who mentioned the single mother with 10 children. I was merely responding to your comment. None of these problems have simple solutions, whether in Mexico or Alaska. My point was that education can help people escape the circumstances of their birth. And as far as condemnation of the protestors, of course I deplore violence. But what about drug cartel violence? What about all of extortion, kidnappings, and murders? Where is the official outrage over the disappeared, not just the 43 students but the thousands or even tens of thousands? As far as I am concerned, official silence equals complicity. It is no wonder that people are fed up.
Actually recent studies in the USA suggest a new hard truth that differs from the experience of the past, that even education can't help most folks rise much up the economic ladder away from the economic situation they're born into. That's in the USA, but in Mexico it's a different story altogether and we have a large population of analfabetos who can't read or write, and such folks are too easily manipulated by a paternalistic government. Education in Mexico offers folks the ability to inform themselves instead of believing the lies they are told by the government, such as Eric Fernández leading folks to believe he already remodeled the pier or that he dredged the entire lagoon or that he's really done anything at all except build his own monument to corruption called the Parque Lineal.
The lawlessness in Guerrero is a bit of a historic problem that (here I go repeating myself again) was strongly exacerbated beginning about 10 years ago when the USA lifted the ban on the purchase of "assault weapons" and almost immediately we saw an increase in firepower and violence throughout Mexico and here in Guerrero.
And I keep repeating that the largest market of stupidly banned substances in the world is what empowers violent organized criminals seeking to protect and consolidate their routes to the USA.
Where is the official outrage? Please, Katherine. Pick up any Mexican newspaper. There is no one in Mexico who isn't outraged over the events of Iguala or the decades long failed "War On Drugs". Did you miss the entire Calderón administration? Everyone was upset with him for accepting money and military hardware from the gringos to fight their stupid proxy war. We have all been outraged for decades over this stupid arrangement between our two countries. What do you want us to do? Build a bigger wall along the border to keep US arms and drug money OUT of Mexico?
Our politicians are a source of constant criticism for their bloated salaries and undeserved privileges as well as for their cronyism and nepotism and opacity, and we don't trust them as far as we can throw them. But you know what? At least they've demonstrated quite clearly that they can put most political differences aside and get together to move the country forward such as they've done during the first 2 years of Enrique Peña Nieto's administration by passing urgently and much needed reforms. Reforms that may not be perfect or please everyone, but THAT is what democracy is all about! Meanwhile we just saw democracy at its worst in the recent US elections and really during the entire presidency of one of the USA's best presidents, from heckling him during a State of the Union address to obstructionism that borders on sedition.
Co-responsibility and cooperation are needed for both countries to tackle the scourge of Prohibition 2.0, but for the moment I just don't see the will in the USA to change their long-failed policy or in Mexico to go it alone. We're still in "Reefer Madness" mentality here, but the US government almost seems to be in denial altogether (and it's a point that really disappoints me about this president who used to get high as a kid).
Mexico is currently moving forward with some excellent legislation led by a promising Senador from Guerrero that should help us do a better job of battling corruption. We are also working on professionalizing our police forces, but we still aren't there yet. And we have made some noteworthy modifications to the justice system, though in my personal opinion I think we need to scrap the codified system and start over again with a more modern system of seeking and imparting justice.
I detect a much needed change in the air, but we need to see how long it lasts and what it engenders. If we're just going to become violent anarchists and rail against the government, the non-poor, and large corporations then things will soon rapidly deteriorate and we can kiss Mexico as we know it goodbye. However, I'm expecting cooler and wiser heads to prevail and for Mexico to get back on track towards resolving its problems as best as it can.
Desviación
by katherine
, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 11:00 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
Thanks for the lesson. I doubt a wall would be much use, since they can always tunnel under. Pobre Mexico. Tan lejos de Dios, tan cerca de los Estados Unidos.
EPN's the best chance of hope?
by HolyMole, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 09:23 (4391 days ago) @ ZihuaRob
I hope your confidence in the current federal administration isn't misplaced.
I just heard about Pena Nieto's $580 million USD presidential jet, reportedly the most expensive of its kind in the world. Couple that with his wife's purchase of that $7 million monstrosity of a mansion reportedly purchased from a Mexican company associated with the Chinese consortium that was the sole bidder on the $3.5 billion USD hi-speed train project, (the contract for which was cancelled by EPN a few days after being awarded, due to "transparency" issues)....and you've got all the signs of an administration that will make Carlos Salinas look like Mr. Clean.
You Think Los Pino's Midget & Actress Would Be Any Different
by mexicowanderer, Thursday, November 13, 2014, 09:41 (4389 days ago) @ HolyMole
Jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja............
The sole hope of the country IMHO is for rapid expansion of Fuerzes Rurales, and Defensas, to SCARE THE LIVING CRAP out of the looters and Napoleon wanna-be's.
You Think Los Pino's Midget & Actress Would Be Any Different
by HolyMole, Thursday, November 13, 2014, 09:58 (4389 days ago) @ mexicowanderer
Jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja............
The sole hope of the country IMHO is for rapid expansion of Fuerzes Rurales, and Defensas, to SCARE THE LIVING CRAP out of the looters and Napoleon wanna-be's.
Interesting ! Just how short is EPN? Not that it should be held against him, of course.
Which reminds me of the classic Peter Cook and Dudley Moore sketch:
You Think Los Pino's Midget & Actress Would Be Any Different
by mexicowanderer, Thursday, November 13, 2014, 12:34 (4389 days ago) @ HolyMole
Methinks that is a death-sentence grade state secret but from all appearances the runt seems to be around 5'4" and weigh-in at a spring sagging 125 lbs.
Remember the song "Short People"?
Carlos Salinas de Chromedome, was obsessive about people NEVER mentioning his squatness. When he campaigned for president of the World Bank, he stood on a 4" box behind the podium at news conferences.
I don't pick on short people. What I pick on is their usual two gigantic blocks of wood they wear on their shoulders.
I do pick on SecGob Osario Chingus. The only person in the world I know of who can speak out of eight sides of his mouth at once.
Aftermath of Iguala
by Gringo Viejo
, Kansas/Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, November 11, 2014, 09:38 (4391 days ago) @ JeffMN
MSNBC is going ballistic today with coverage of this subject. Hourly broadcasts on-site in Apapulco.

