SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Amennn, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 09:32 (4257 days ago)

See original thread originated March 1.

I have spent the last 3 weeks on this.

OK - Time for facts. I started getting my rent money together on Feb 28 at the Scotiabank downtown, at the ATM. I got no money. Tried again. Same thing. Error messages read 'cant communicate with bank' and 'limit exceeded'. So next day, same thing, next day same thing. So I checked online and saw all the charges, totalling nearly 1200 dollars. Since then I filed a fraud claim, and my US bank investigated, and two days ago I got the five page printout from Scotia that was sent to my bank to "prove" that I got my money. Anyone who knows Scotia knows the big Security Guard who used to be there, named "Segovia" cause he spoke perfect English. He is my witness that I got no money. BUT I am out 1200 bucks, and Scotia's accounting at that ATM is the reason. It is not my US bank ... It is Scotia. I encourage all affected GRINGOS to boycoatt SCOTIA until those people refund the money. I waited forever for an audience with the manager and was blown off. I will try this Monday again, and withdraw my money and cancel my account. This is an outrage. I have heard of bank robbers but never thought it would apply to the bankers. Call it what you want. In law it is called "conversion". I know the law. Don't bother to argue. This is fact, my story, and SCOTIA needs better internal controls, or to find anyone inside who is milking the machines, or rigging them like Las Vegas.:-o :-(

--

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by BobIr ⌂ @, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A., Saturday, March 21, 2015, 10:12 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

For years I've used the ATM at Banamex. This year my card didn't work, nor my daughter's, who was with me. A local woman who spoke English helped us and pointed out we didn't have a chip on the back of our card.

Trudged to Scotia and both cards worked fine and we used their ATMs the rest of our week there with no problems.

Sorry you had problems and I hope you're able to resolve them. My guess is it's an isolated incident, which I know doesn't help you. You're still out the money and no doubt it will be hard to resolve.

As a side bar just got notified by our bank that new debit cards with the chip now needed in many other countries is being sent to us.

--
Follow Bob & Millie's adventures with their photo galleries on SmugMug.
http://bobmillie.smugmug.com/

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by HolyMole, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 10:15 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

See original thread originated March 1.

I have spent the last 3 weeks on this.

OK - Time for facts. I started getting my rent money together on Feb 28 at the Scotiabank downtown, at the ATM. I got no money. Tried again. Same thing. Error messages read 'cant communicate with bank' and 'limit exceeded'. So next day, same thing, next day same thing. So I checked online and saw all the charges, totalling nearly 1200 dollars. Since then I filed a fraud claim, and my US bank investigated, and two days ago I got the five page printout from Scotia that was sent to my bank to "prove" that I got my money. Anyone who knows Scotia knows the big Security Guard who used to be there, named "Segovia" cause he spoke perfect English. He is my witness that I got no money. BUT I am out 1200 bucks, and Scotia's accounting at that ATM is the reason. It is not my US bank ... It is Scotia. I encourage all affected GRINGOS to boycoatt SCOTIA until those people refund the money. I waited forever for an audience with the manager and was blown off. I will try this Monday again, and withdraw my money and cancel my account. This is an outrage. I have heard of bank robbers but never thought it would apply to the bankers. Call it what you want. In law it is called "conversion". I know the law. Don't bother to argue. This is fact, my story, and SCOTIA needs better internal controls, or to find anyone inside who is milking the machines, or rigging them like Las Vegas.:-o :-(

--

Amenn, brother. That ATM has been malfunctioning for well over a year: that the security guard is the ATM "go to" guy is laughable - where is the branch manager?
Good luck. We're even more exposed....all our money is in Scotiabank Canada.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by juanrojo @, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 10:36 (4257 days ago) @ HolyMole

As a Canadian with more understanding of one of our major banks I would try contacting a toll free representative in Canada to pursue this situation for you . I might be blowing smoke out my ass that they would care or act on your behalf but that would be my approach .

--
Please be happy always

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Amennn, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 10:56 (4257 days ago) @ HolyMole

Hi Hole Mole :)

Yeah, it has been weird, and though I have heard stories that suggest that hopefully it might be an isolated incident, I have also heard stories like mine confirming what happened to me. My card is new, so it has latest technology. Works at Santander, Bancomer...

Meanwhile, I would rather have my lost money go to Segovia, the honest, English speaking bank guard, than to the corporation or local bankers, but that is a pipe dream. There was a new guard there the other day and a red warning over the ATM- don't use it, said the new guy, in Spanish. Fine. ATM Still having problems 22 days later.

What could be semi-plausible as an explanation at SCOTIA is this: The ATM ran out of money, the machine didn't sense it and when cards were inserted the machine thought it was counting out money and logged it in the counting mechanism, but the feeder mechanism that puts the 500s, 200s, and 100s out into the cash dispenser had nothing there to dispense, even though the guts of the machine said otherwise. That is the only thing I can figure that would survive my bank's fraud audit of the SCOTIA records. But counting the tills should have caught it, I would think. Anyway.....

But even with Segovia as my witness, I have lost my $$$, so far. So heads-up to you Scotia folks.

I wonder how many Snowbirds and vacationers have been hosed, don't know about this message board and just 'sucked it up' and wrote it off, or wont know until next month that they have been hosed?

A lot, I bet.. but we will never know.

Live and learn.

P.S.

If anyone out there in BULLETIN BOARD LAND knows someone at SCOTIA by name that has authority and speaks a little English, or fluently, I WOULD APPRECIATE A REFERRAL.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by frostbite @, Hamilton MT, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 11:02 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

Our real estate trust is held by Scotia in Acapulco, rather than Zihua. Assuming that the Acapulco branch is probably bigger, there might be someone there with better English and more stroke. Might be worth a try.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 11:03 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

In this day and age of scammers who use all kinds of tricks on cajeros automáticos I wouldn't be so quick to blame the bank. If the bank says you received your money but you didn't, then a review of the security camera video should help you, but don't wait too long to request it.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Linda from Canada @, Zihua and Grand Marais, Manitoba, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 13:45 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

If you want to go and see the manager but your spanish isn't up for it, why not use a professional translator? I recommend Alberto. He has helped many foreigners with appointments at banks, immigration and medical situations. He is very experienced and realizes the differences in some of the systems for foreigners. Many folks have said it has been well worth having him come along- sure reduces the stress to feel there is someone there to speak on your behalf. Reach him by email at alberto.irodriguez.g@gmail.com or on his cell at 755-55-77-153.

Just for my 2 pesos worth- I am not impressed with the present manager at this branch. I could be wrong, but based on my personal experience, I got the feeling that he doesn't have much interest in serving foreigners. That is putting it mildly, but politely.

--
Linda from Canada
check out my books at www.livingthedreaminmexico.com AND please have a look at www.cookingwithclaudiainzihuatanejo.blogspot.com as well as www.albertoinzihuatanejo.blogspot.com

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by HolyMole, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 10:18 (4256 days ago) @ Amennn

Don't know if this will help or not, but the shotgun approach sometimes works.

Send an e-mail to the President of Scotiabank, in Toronto, at:
mail.president@scotiabank.com
explaining your problem. When his office replies, they'll tell you that Scotiabank Canada has no control over the operations of Scotiabank Mexico. So, anticipating that response, tell them how disappointed you are that an internationally-respected bank would offer such poor service to travelers who thought they could depend on the usually-reliable Canadian banking procedures associated with the Scotiabank name....yadda, yadda. Even tell them you realize that Scotiabank Mexico may operate fairly independently from the Canadian operation, but that it's the international Scotiabank "brand" that's being tarnished by this one branch in Zihuatanejo. Tell them about Segovia. Tell them about the local branch manager's indifference. Tell them their damn ATM has been unreliable for at least a year or more. Request that his office forward your complaint to the responsible people at Scotiabank Mexico. (They'll probably provide you with the e-mail addresses, and expect you to contact them.)
Oh, and tell them if it does take months and months to straighten this mess out, that you assume they'll pay you the same interest rates for borrowing your $1200 as they would charge if they'd lent you the $1200.
Buena suerte.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 11:00 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

You should contact PROFECO.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Amennn, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 12:10 (4257 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

THANK YOU, ROB .....

and thank you for the video camera suggestion as well, who knows?

Your suggestions are practical and helpful, and I appreciate them very much.

I also enjoy your photos of Zihua. I have lived here 3 years now full time and never had a $$$ problem before.

I will not forget your helpfulness.

Que vayas bien, y muchisimas gracias :)

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by La Cumbre @, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 16:51 (4257 days ago) @ Amennn

This may help or may not. At HSBC last year I processed for money and as happened to you no money. HSBC not help said I needed to go through my bank CIBC in Canada which I did. They said that the ATM's are operated by an independent and that they would file an investigation which they did. They told me it could take up to 8 plus weeks and it took about 7 but I got my money because the 3rd party has to provide the back-up that they were over or short on that transaction and obviously they were over the amount I never got and CIBC deposited in my account but a long long wait.

I hope this is the same for you, now I only go to Santander across the street (this is in Ixtapa). I was not provided with an answer as to what happened but then again once they deposited the amount back in my account I never asked.

I will say though that with previous bank transfers between HSBC and CIBC or international money orders it was a long long road to make it happen. In my opinion between CIBC in Canada and HSBC here not sure what to say but not impressed with several years of this and that with either bank. They make enough money that they (your bank) should give you yours and then they can settle the matter but with so many transactions that failed and you being charged something seems wacky.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Cindy in Oregon, Saturday, March 21, 2015, 21:31 (4257 days ago) @ La Cumbre

Hoping my similar situation is resolved. Mine happened March 1st and both banks are still working on it. (yeah, I tried another card after the first one gave me an error-cancelling transaction message. Silly me!)

SIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGH

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Canadian Rainbirds ⌂ @, Victoria BC and Zihuatanejo, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 09:32 (4256 days ago) @ La Cumbre

This may help or may not. At HSBC last year I processed for money and as happened to you no money. HSBC not help said I needed to go through my bank CIBC in Canada which I did. They said that the ATM's are operated by an independent and that they would file an investigation which they did. They told me it could take up to 8 plus weeks and it took about 7 but I got my money because the 3rd party has to provide the back-up that they were over or short on that transaction and obviously they were over the amount I never got and CIBC deposited in my account but a long long wait.

I hope this is the same for you, now I only go to Santander across the street (this is in Ixtapa). I was not provided with an answer as to what happened but then again once they deposited the amount back in my account I never asked.
. . . . .


Same thing happened to us in Mazatlan years ago at I think a Santender ATM. Reported to CIBC branch at home, money was refunded months later. To be fair, I was told at the time by CIBC it would take quite a while--they have to depend on the foreign ATM operator for information.

Good Luck

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 17:56 (4256 days ago) @ Canadian Rainbirds

When something similar happened to me several years ago, my Credit Union put the money back in my account in less than 3 weeks.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Mexalberta @, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 18:44 (4256 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

May have missed it, but has there been any instances of this at thee Scotia ATM at Commercial or just at the bank.
If that is the case I would be very suspicious.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:17 (4256 days ago) @ Mexalberta
edited by LadyM in Zihua, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:54

I do not know the answer to your question, but the ATM machine at the bank has had problems for several years. It and the one at La Comer are nothing alike. They both do not take the card totally inside.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Mexalberta @, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:28 (4256 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

I am only familiar with the La Comer machine. It Only takes the card part way in.
we also use one at Mega in Bucerias that is the same

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:53 (4256 days ago) @ Mexalberta

I am only familiar with the La Comer machine. It Only takes the card part way in.
we also use one at Mega in Bucerias that is the same

The machine at Scotia Bank is the same for the card. I have used it for several years.

The problem I had with money was not there and was one of my making. I put in my card, put in the amount I wanted and out it came. I dropped all the stuff in my hand in the floor and bent over to pick it up when I heard this horrible sucking sound. Back into the machine my money went. When I tried to take money out again it said I had already withdrawn my allotted amount for the day. I talked to management at Banorte and was told there was nothing they could do. Called my credit union and they had the entire amount back in my account in less than three weeks.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Steve @, Monday, March 23, 2015, 13:56 (4255 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Same thing happened to me in Japan last year. As an aside, In Japan the bank atms don't work for foreign banks atm cards so 7-11 atms are where you get your money??!! Just very weird. So my money comes flying out of the 7 -11 atm, I dropped some things and bent over to pick them up and, whoosh, my money got sucked back into the machine. Of course I wondered whether I would get double-debited when I asked for more money but it never happened, so my experience was different than yours.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Monday, March 23, 2015, 16:24 (4255 days ago) @ Steve

At least we both had satisfactory outcomes.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by Leemr @, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 15:26 (4256 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

In my experience fighting HSBC in the past, PROFECO passed me on to CONDUSEF. They are the federal organization that deals with ordinary people and financial institutions. There is a branch in Acapulco on Costera Aleman. I needed to make a number of trips (appointments) to finally resolve my issue. HSBC sent nobody to the meetings until the last appointment. I was very satisfied with the efficiency of CONDUSEF. You should have all the details, times and dates and paper work with you. Also your passport. Good Luck.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE -Shorted 500 Pesos

by carter, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:26 (4256 days ago) @ Leemr

Withdrew 5,000 pesos from Scotia Bank in down town Z with a Charles Schwab ATM card on March 10, 2015 and was shorted 500 pesos. They told me to report to Schwab. I did and we will see what happens.No news yet. Will keep you posted. FYI Schwab refunds all ATM fees. Able to withdraw 7,000 pesos from Santander at a time but only 5,000 from Scotia. Will no longer be using their ATM.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE -Shorted 500 Pesos

by karenanddick, Tuesday, March 24, 2015, 17:03 (4254 days ago) @ carter

Same thing happened to us last year with Scotia Bank. Shorted about $170 USD. I called Schwab and the money was back in our account the next day. I had no receipt but Schwab said don't worry about it. It was their problem I was told. Love Charlie!

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE -Shorted 500 Pesos

by HolyMole, Tuesday, March 24, 2015, 17:21 (4254 days ago) @ karenanddick

Same thing happened to us last year with Scotia Bank. Shorted about $170 USD. I called Schwab and the money was back in our account the next day. I had no receipt but Schwab said don't worry about it. It was their problem I was told. Love Charlie!

If the Zihua Scotiabank branch had any sense whatsoever of "customer service" or "corporate responsibility", (I know - an oxymoron), they would:

--publicly acknowledge that their ATM has been unreliable for years
--immediately fire whichever company they've apparently contracted-out
their ATM business to
--until they can replace their ATM with reliable, state-of-the-art
equipment, honour all legitimate customer claims of short-changes and/or
missing funds. Clients acting in good faith who've lost hundreds of
dollars due to Scotiabank's incompetence shouldn't have to wait weeks or
months for return of their own money.

I feel better already.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE -Shorted 500 Pesos

by LadyM in Zihua, Tuesday, March 24, 2015, 17:58 (4254 days ago) @ HolyMole

I do too, and I don't even agree with everything you said. Funny how stuff like that helps.

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE -Shorted 500 Pesos

by carter, Wednesday, March 25, 2015, 07:04 (4254 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Schwab put the money back in my account. It was only $33.00 US dollars but still frustrating to be shorted cash from Scotia Bank ATM. I feel better now.

social media?

by Cindy in Oregon, Sunday, March 22, 2015, 21:51 (4256 days ago) @ Amennn

I posted to Scotia's FB page. I will post to their twitter account tomorrow. Sometimes social media can get attention when other means can't.

Avatar

social media?

by DEBMN @, rosemount mn, Tuesday, March 24, 2015, 11:15 (4254 days ago) @ Cindy in Oregon

This same thing happened to my husband Greg. The bank put the money back into his account within a week. We had brought enough cash to exchange at the bank thank goodness!

Hope it all turns out okay for everyone else that had the same problem.

Avatar

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by jaui @, Zihuatanejo, Tuesday, March 24, 2015, 02:34 (4255 days ago) @ Amennn

3/24/2015

My logic tells me that it is easy to prove that you received NO cash.
Let me see if I can explain.
For example, if the machine was stocked with 100,000 pesos.
You withdrew 8,000 total, just for this example.
And according to the cash withdrawls done, including yours, 50,000 was dispensed at the ATM, then, 50,000 should still be a physically countable sum of cash to verify.
If the cash could of been counted, and they found 58,000, it seems to me, that would PROVE you did NOT get your 8,000 pesos.
I have no idea, if that physical cash count check could of been done, or is an option in this type of case, though.
To me, it sounds logical, but, I could be way off base???:-o

--
jaui

SCOTIA NIGHTMARE - UPDATE

by carter, Wednesday, March 25, 2015, 07:09 (4254 days ago) @ jaui

Yes, they can do that. At the end of day when they reconcile they can tell if they did not dispense the right amount of cash. Or, they should be able to. Not sure about Scotia Bank.

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by HolyMole, Thursday, March 26, 2015, 17:22 (4252 days ago) @ Amennn

As an account-holder and long-time client of Scotiabank,(and, he admitted with a red face, until recently - a shareholder), I've been as frustrated as anyone else with the unreliable ATM service at their Zihua branch, and sympathetic of the problems others have been having, (problems worse than my simple frustration: I haven't had any funds withdrawn from my Scotiabank account incorrectly....yet.)
So I thought I would try, once again, to involve the people at the bank's headquarters, in Toronto, to see if I could shake them up a tad.
Here's their response to my recent e-mail:

Dear Mr. (HolyMole)

Thank you for your e-mail received in our office 24-03-2015. We have forwarded your email to our International Banking Group who will initiate an investigation and respond to you directly. Please be assured our office will follow to ensure a response is provided to you.

Thank you for writing to us.

Sincerely,


Amelie Caron
Manager - Office of the President
Scotiabank - Executive Offices
e-mail: mail.president@scotiabank.com
Telephone: (416) 933-1700 or (877) 700-0043 FREE
Fax: (416) 933-1777 or (877) 700-0045 FREE

So, we'll see what, if anything, transpires. I told them to check out Rob's Message Board if they doubted my claims. Hope that's kosher, Rob.

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by norm, Friday, March 27, 2015, 16:33 (4251 days ago) @ HolyMole

Three bank nightmare.Went to bank,put in card in ATM,was refused,went to another bank across street,was refused,went to another,same result.Back to Santander,had bank manager come out with me and watch everything.Card refused.He the took out card and said (I thougt)quite sympathetically),this is a credit card.not a debit card

Avatar

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by frostbite @, Hamilton MT, Friday, March 27, 2015, 16:48 (4251 days ago) @ norm

Back before I got an ATM card from our local credit union, I'd get cash with my Visa credit card. The only time I had a problem was when I forgot to call them to tell them that I'd be traveling.

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by K&B @, Friday, March 27, 2015, 18:53 (4251 days ago) @ norm

Of all the things that I am worried about with travel in Mexico, running out of money (atm) ranks pretty high. This needs to be fixed

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Friday, March 27, 2015, 19:44 (4251 days ago) @ K&B

Never worry about running out of money. There are lots of options.

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by K&B @, Friday, March 27, 2015, 19:47 (4251 days ago) @ LadyM in Zihua

Tell me?

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by LadyM in Zihua, Friday, March 27, 2015, 21:15 (4251 days ago) @ K&B

Bring some emergency dollars that can be exchanged at the bank or the money exchange. Bring more than one ATM card from different accounts. If something happens to one you have the other.
I sent a money gram to myself before I left to come here. Picked up the pesos in Electra.
Those are just some of the things you can do if you are worried about being able to get pesos. I did it to try and see which one was right for me to get the best exchange rate. I think ATM's all the way.

Avatar

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by ZihuaRob ⌂ @, Zihuatanejo, México, Friday, March 27, 2015, 19:53 (4251 days ago) @ HolyMole

So, we'll see what, if anything, transpires. I told them to check out Rob's Message Board if they doubted my claims. Hope that's kosher, Rob.

That certainly is, amigo.

A letter from the office manager. Wow! :beatwall:

SCOTIABANK - UPDATE TO THE UPDATE

by HolyMole, Saturday, March 28, 2015, 09:07 (4251 days ago) @ ZihuaRob

So, we'll see what, if anything, transpires. I told them to check out Rob's Message Board if they doubted my claims. Hope that's kosher, Rob.


That certainly is, amigo.

A letter from the office manager. Wow! :beatwall:

I think "Manager - Office of the President" sounds a lot more impressive. ;-)